dark light

thobbes

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 15 posts - 1,831 through 1,845 (of 2,012 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: Navies news from around the world -IV #2006820
    thobbes
    Participant

    What’s the ship that’s the Type 42 has crashed into?

    in reply to: Navies news from around the world -IV #2006828
    thobbes
    Participant

    It is rather telling in that it confirms the dire state of the Argentine navy.

    The other telling tales included the impounding of the Argentine training ship and the stranding of a corvette in South Africa following a breakdown.

    Kirchener may bark but there’s no bite in this toothless dog.

    in reply to: F35 News only thread for 2013 #2255867
    thobbes
    Participant

    Funny how things turns out , 3 wars already for the “pedestrian bomb truck”

    Cheers .

    To be fair, those 3 wars have only required Rafale to be used as a pedestrian bomb truck.

    Modernised A-1 Skyraiders would’ve been just as useful.

    The Rafale (and Eurofighter) are still unproven in a proper warfighting scenario.

    in reply to: Navies news from around the world -IV #2006836
    thobbes
    Participant

    Well the picture says it all really! The ARA Santísima Trinidad has sunk in dock!

    With only a caretaker crew it looks like her material state got the better of her.

    http://www.infobae.com/adjuntos/jpg/2013/01/600x0_626898.jpg

    http://www.infobae.com/notas/692513-Un-buque-fuera-de-servicio-sufrio-una-averia-y-evacuaron-al-personal.html

    Wow. I suppose she has been non-operational since 1980s though.

    in reply to: Navies news from around the world -IV #2006840
    thobbes
    Participant

    They are also apparently looking at less than 12 subs as well. Given they can’t furnish enough crews for 6, 12 seems like a pipe dream dependent on the reintroduction of conscription. :p

    The surface fleet is slowly shrinking – I think it was 15 hulls in 1980s (3 destroyer, 12 destroyer escort/frigate) and then 12 and now 11.

    Even the extensively used patrol fleet has shrunk by 1 boat from 15 to 14.

    Whilst shrinkage or conversion to OPV forces is fine for European Navies who don’t have any serious threats, the situation in Asia is reverse with not only growing China but other powers as well (e.g. Australia and India haven’t been too chummy since attacks and murders of Indian students in Australia).

    And then there’s been increased demands on RN since Cold War finished – Persian Gulf, anti-piracy, increased border protection patrols especially with illiegal immigration.

    RAN’s warships may be very modern but Australia has a huge coastline.

    Also interesting that the two Canberra class LHD’s are very undergunned – 4 x 25mm guns.

    in reply to: French air campaign – Mali #2255891
    thobbes
    Participant

    Morrocans and Algerians don’t generally get invovled in sub Saharan Africa. Libya was the only African Arab country with an interest in sub-Saharan Afirca.

    Africa is not like NATO where you have close cooperation and involvement between the vast majority of players.

    in reply to: Military Aviation News-2013 #2256346
    thobbes
    Participant
    in reply to: Is American aviation going downhill? #2258366
    thobbes
    Participant

    Agree to most of your statements! But your last point

    I can not 🙁
    For I think it is thew U.S military that is its own biggest enemy!! For it is the well known and instatutionalised process of defence industries rewarding U.S. Military program top brass corporate jobs at the end of winning a contract and their product is aquired, that has far out stripped bureuacracy my friend! Anywhere else and it would be called kickback and fratanisation! ISadly in today’ U.S. defence/defence industry it has long become the excepted norm 🙁

    I did mean the military’s own bureaucracy (that includes top brass). Sorry I worded that badly.

    in reply to: French air campaign – Mali #2258452
    thobbes
    Participant

    Well spotted!

    Gaddafi was loved in some African quarters thanks to aid and promises of African revival.

    in reply to: Is American aviation going downhill? #2258457
    thobbes
    Participant

    Another point I forgot to make.

    Procurement in the West has become too politicised with too much emphasis on economic objectives and little emphasis on defence ones.

    In the US the situation is so bad that the US military cannot make sensible rationalisation decisions due to Congressional disapproval (e.g. consolidation of strategic transpor and ANG units and retirement of old ships).

    The result of this is less money and resources for key areas.

    Congress seems to view the US military as a job creation scheme.

    The US’ biggest enemies are Congress and it’s own bureuacracy.

    in reply to: Is American aviation going downhill? #2258550
    thobbes
    Participant

    I’d say yes from a military perspective.

    The US militiary development process seems to have become extremely inefficient in terms of both cost and outcomes..

    Whilst we talk about F-35, F-22, MV-22 etc, the vast bulk of the US military is equipped with ancient junk that’s being patched up to get maximum life out of it.

    Look at the age of bomber fleet, tanker fleet, tactical transport fleet (still mainly C-130H), and even fighter fleet (most date from the 1980s or 1990s).

    Development cycles have become extremely protracted (literally decades) and expensive and difficult to produce fully operational aircraft (e.g. only a bit over half of all the F-22s are combat coded with full operational software).

    Just about every major program has had massive problems (F-22, F-35) E-10 (cancelled), RAH-66 (cancelled), KC-46 program etc etc. Sikorsky civilian S-92 has also had issues (e.g. look at RCAF).

    Only relative success stories have been the F/A-18E/F, C-17, C-130J and these had issues as well. Upgrade programs seem to be the only real success story in terms of efficiency and effectiveness but these are old airframe designs and in many instances it’s old aircraft being refurbished and not new builds.

    And the US is having to look to foreign countries for more and more systems:

    1. Trainers – T-6 = PC-9, T-45 = Bae Hawk. T-38 replacement will be either Italian or South Korean.

    2. Light helos – UH-72 (Eurocopter)

    3. Light tactical transports – have been foreign built since Vietnam (Caribou and then C-27).

    And it’s not just aircraft, it’s also navy (LCS, DDG1000) and ground forces (e.g. issues with M4 magazines, UMSC amphibious vehicle).

    The saving graces:

    1. Excellent troop training
    2. Excellent logistics systems
    3. Other powers are starting from a lot lower level (e.g. Russia/China) and have a lot of catching up to do.
    4. Defence budget is still the largest in the world
    5. The US picks on low hanging fruit for its wars and in most cases fruit that’s rotting on the ground.

    The problem is you can only keep patching up old aircraft/equipment for so long before they get retired.

    in reply to: French air campaign – Mali #2259376
    thobbes
    Participant

    (I wouldn’t count the RF-4E shoot down though…it doesn’t deliver ordnance

    Mirage F1CR doesn’t drop ordnance either. It’s also a recce bird.

    in reply to: French air campaign – Mali #2259391
    thobbes
    Participant

    Conflict spills over into Algeria with 41 foreigners apparently taken hostage.

    http://www.thestar.com/news/world/article/1316132–mali-conflict-spills-into-algeria-as-foreigners-taken-hostage

    in reply to: French air campaign – Mali #2259393
    thobbes
    Participant

    So where’s the Charles de Gaulle in all of this?

    Sure Mali is a landlocked countrry but a carrier is still useful as a floating base or for delivering troops/choppers/etc? The US used carrier aviation in landlocked Afghanistan as did the French.

    Also haven’t heard any news about the use of any of the 3 Mistrals in support either.

    in reply to: French air campaign – Mali #2259395
    thobbes
    Participant

    Pretty sure the Turks used F-4s to drop bombs on Kurdish positions in 2011 or 2012.

    And they’re still obviously conducting recce flights with them.

    Last bomb totting French Mirage F1s were retired this year.

    Spanish Air Forces has used Mirage F1s in active role in Baltic Air Policing Mission.

Viewing 15 posts - 1,831 through 1,845 (of 2,012 total)