dark light

JSR

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 15 posts - 3,601 through 3,615 (of 4,319 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: RuAF News and Development Thread 9 #2306888
    JSR
    Participant

    Considering the Su-33 had its effective fuel and payload capacity reduced by 1/3rd on STOBAR ops, I’m surprised the MiG-29K only has 1000kg knocked off.

    But yeah, any weight savings due to removal of wing folding mechanisms and increased use of composites etc in the MiG-35 would be negligible.

    Su-33 has canards compared to basic SU-27SK.
    Su-33 has reduced range and performance compared to lighter Su-27SK.
    http://www.sukhoi.org/eng/planes/military/su33/lth/

    MIG-29K look more advanced as its has identical range on internal fuel with MIG-29M. so penalty from carrier operations not big.

    in reply to: RuAF News and Development Thread 9 #2306891
    JSR
    Participant

    Total over 2500 sorties in short 2008 skirmish.

    http://government.ru/eng/docs/19357/
    At that time, we used the integrated system of organising flights, which allowed us to make over 2,500 flights without prior requests by bomber, fighter, military transport and assault aircraft. As a result, the air navigation experts who took part in that operation received commendations from the Defence Ministry leadership.

    in reply to: Shenyang J-21/31/F-60/AMF thread part 1 #2307447
    JSR
    Participant

    You realize everything you said could be applied to T-50 as well? :p

    PAK-FA will be flying higher and faster than anything out there. i doubt line of sight probable. even use of afterburner has minimilst impact.

    http://mw2.google.com/mw-panoramio/photos/medium/57747100.jpg
    https://acesflyinghigh.files.wordpress.com/2012/05/f22-afterburner.jpg

    There is always TVC to flip around in a moment to show the stealthy face. The more boxy design you make the less stealthy and less range.

    in reply to: RuAF News and Development Thread 9 #2307528
    JSR
    Participant

    Thanks.

    Given these aircraft will be serving for the next 20-30 years the Indian Navy should have ordered the 30 additional MiG-29Ks with the MiG-35 avionics suite. Ah, but the wisdom of our MoD…:rolleyes:

    Indian Navy is doing fine. they can be upgraded in later.
    Its IAF that is lacking wisdom. They are buying aircraft in 21st century with small nose and weak engines. Strong engines and large nose is must for AESA.
    with little prospects of leap frog in electronic technologies as French state funding support is not on same level as US/Russia/China. and that will not likely ever change. and that not even including current uncompetitivness.

    in reply to: RuAF News and Development Thread 9 #2307530
    JSR
    Participant

    Can’t be helped, I guess. The RuAF has no suitable UAVs and sometimes you need more than satellite reconnaisance.

    for tactical recon. they had Israeli UAV.

    MIG-25 is still usefull for lifting heavier equipment and flying fast/high near protected targets in one off situations.

    in reply to: RuAF News and Development Thread 9 #2308061
    JSR
    Participant

    Question for the experts,

    The MiG-29K/M is quoted as having a 5500kg payload capacity while the MiG-35 is advertised with 6500kg payload.

    Given the MiG-35 is identical to the MiG-29M except for the avionics and has the same engines, how was this 1-tonne increase in payload achieved?

    Or is it just a case inconsistent information?

    your referring to old MIG-29M. New MIG-29M is identical with MIG-29K. and has 6500kg. see page 21. infact with new engines ground level speed is now 1500km/h for MIG-29M. All 3 fighters have 6500kg external payload. if u ignore the typo.

    http://www.roe.ru/cataloque/air_craft/aircraft_20-24.pdf

    in reply to: PLAAF Thread 15 #2308794
    JSR
    Participant

    CAC also state owned, and does CAC self funded FC-1/JF-17 get any order from PLAAF or PLANAF? Have you heard FC-1/JF-17 being called ” J-x”?

    FC-1 has signed up customer from start. and this is even more dysfunctional design than J-20. large wing, short length with tall tails. range, internal weopon and performance will be very low (lack of supercruise/high altitude). this may well become overweight. it is black so it must be stealth.

    in reply to: RuAF News and Development Thread 9 #2308999
    JSR
    Participant

    It seems there are two firms that producing AESA modules and first time GaN

    http://www.micran.ru/about/activity/
    2. Single-and multi-function microwave modules

    Microwave Electronics is one of the priorities of the NPF “Micran.” The company has many years of experience in the development and production of a wide range of single and multi-function modules in the microwave monolithic and hybrid monolithic design, rapidly developing technology design and production – up to the mass – monolithic integrated circuits nanoheterostructures GaAs and GaN.

    The company has mastered the technology of designing and production of transceiver modules active phased antenna arrays (AESA) based on its own ECB microwave and high-measurement systems. On the technology developed and mastered in mass production series receivers, transceiver modules AESA L, S, C, X band radar for ground-based, airborne and space-based.

    As an example, the MRP for the first Russian radar, built by AESA technology for the MiG-35, receiving modules for radar “Sky-M”. The development of several projects AESA X-band, including active antenna digital sublattice synthetic aperture radar space-based.

    http://www.forumtvm.ru/en/news/item/news_id-179.htm
    “Research & Production Corporation Istok” will introduce its Integrated Circuit

    Federal State Unitary Enterprise “Research & Production Corporation Istok” will introduce its Integrated Circuit for the Active Phased Antenna Array at the Forum ET 2012

    The Federal State Unitary Enterprise ISTOK will present at the Forum “Engineering Technologies 2012” a monolithic integrated circuit designed for installation in the combined modules of the active phased antenna arrays for the fifth-generation jet fighters to enhance their power. Last year, this circuit won the Golden Chip Award for innovations and outstanding performance.
    The circuit is called core-chip and is based on nano heterostructures GaAs. The multi-functional system has the most state-of-the-art innovations and can replace almost 11 integrated circuits from the previous generation. This will decrease the mass-dimensional indicators and enhance its reliability due to the reduced number of welded and soldered joints.

    in reply to: Military Aviation News-2012 #2309173
    JSR
    Participant

    They still produce F-15s and F-16s in America – how old are they?

    F-16E weigh as much as Rafale (aircraft with much larger wing area). and F-15K is heavier than Su-30MK2 (which itself is not modern material aircraft).

    F-18E weight is considerably more than MIG-29K/Rafale without producing more capability/performance.
    it is strictly weight and aerodynamic comparision not electronic.

    .

    in reply to: Russian Civil Aviation News #532579
    JSR
    Participant

    Just to be clear: For Russian Civil Aviation program, UAC will be fokus with SSJ for capacity below 140, while 140 to 200 will be the domain of MS-21, right ?

    Thus this means TU 204 plug will be terminated ? Could Ukraine can further developed An-148 without Russia (since the capacity of AN-148 will be on SSJ domain) ?

    Tu-204/214 has special & long versions. i dont think they will stop building it. and who knows in 10 years what kind of relationship with EU.
    Infact Putin said new widebody/heavy lift chopper will be built in Far East. so with time decrease cooperation with EU manufacturers as it will become uneconomical to bring parts

    http://www.wcarn.com/cache/news/21/21248.html

    Chinese pilot finish qualifying course on Tu-204. I think they will eventually want special version of Tu-214 just like IL-476.
    http://www.tupolev.ru/english/Show.asp?SectionID=35

    JSR
    Participant

    Putin disagrees, in fact he wants to try talking about the islands again this weekend
    http://www.marketwatch.com/story/japan-russia-agree-to-renew-talks-on-islands-2012-09-08

    Japan disagrees, they are willing to let themselves be hooked on Russian energy after this recent LNG pact.

    Putin statements gives false hopes to countries to induce them into cooperation but in reality he kicks them from behind.
    see this example. Putin intention is to discredit Islam by creating fight within Islam. but he is giving statement to the opposite.

    https://rt.com/news/vladimir-putin-exclusive-interview-481/
    Luckily, we generally enjoy friendly relations with the Arab world, but we would like to stay away from Islamic sectarian conflict, or interfere in a showdown involving the Sunnis, the Shia, the Alawis and so on. We treat everyone with equal respect. We also get on well with Saudi Arabia and other countries; I have cultivated a warm personal relationship with the custodian of two Islamic shrines.

    Japan is bankrupt. manufacturing is fleeing Japan at fastest pace. There is complete lack of R&D & skill manpower for moving into new generation technologies to diversify the economic. Japan standards of living will continue to fall untill it become a third world country. see the low contractor wages in Japan nuclear power industry. Japan LNG deal is more sign of desperation.

    in reply to: Pak-Fa news thread part 21 #2310891
    JSR
    Participant

    We do?!? :confused:

    Than your not a break through research but more like incremental improvements to very minute part of engineering.
    the point i am making is the people working on 5G fighters at higher level will not be tempted by 10 fold pay check increase as they are handsomely compensated already due to very unique nature of project.
    And Putin association with 5G fighters is much longer than his association with Football. (see world cup bid, hiring of expensive coaches, players, football clubs).

    so the project failure due to lack of money is simply not going to happen.

    see this from year 2000 . and before that he visited Maks-99. All those predictions come true with UAC consolidation.

    http://forums.airbase.ru/2000/05/t14355–russian-s-37-accelerates-fighter-technology.6420.html
    27.05.2000
    Russian S-37 Accelerates
    Fighter Technology
    CRAIG COVAULT/MOSCOW
    But the Sukhoi director has close ties to new Russian President Vladimir Putin, and this could aid the S-37 program, which earlier had been shunned by some senior officers in the Russian Defense Ministry. “Putin has taken a special interest in our company,” Pogosyan said.
    A new Sukhoi heavy fighter design will not necessarily involve a forward-swept wing. But the composite materials development and fabrication techniques and flight control technologies embodied in the S-37 will benefit Russian fighter designs well into the next two decades.
    Pogosyan believes Putin will aid the reform at Sukhoi and other Russian companies. “Now there is deep interest by the government in the Russian military industrial complex,” he said. And Putin is also especially familiar with Sukhoi.
    The Sukhoi director said one of Putin’s main objectives is to exert more government oversight of hard currency flowing into Russia for arms sales and funneling some of that funding into the establishment of aerospace holding companies.
    Pogosyan said this should help to focus Russian military aerospace priorities and better coordinate the development efforts that are selected.

    JSR
    Participant

    http://en.for-ua.com/interview/2012/09/06/165947.html
    China is known for its fast developing and wide-range production. There are Chinese cars, motorbikes, even tractors. Why don’t we fly in Chinese planes?

    – Indeed, China has succeeded in many industries, but the aircraft production is still a new area for it. The first project – ARJ-21 plane – was not much of a success, though we helped them with calculations. China does not have enough experience to come to the big market.

    China once copied our An-24. It was an old plane with out-of-date aerodynamics. They installed Canadian helicopter engines and replaced navigation equipment, but the airframe and gears are ours. First they called it Yun-7, now it is MA-60, but it fact it is good old An-24.

    – Have you appealed to court?

    – No, we prefer to cooperate with China. Besides, the planes were designed back in Soviet times and the chance to win is not very high. We had similar lawsuits in the past. Poland, for example, assembles An-28 without license. We appealed to court and won the case, but they said the contract on production was concluded with USSR, and USSR’s heir is Russia, which does not have any claims.

    in reply to: Pak-Fa news thread part 21 #2311976
    JSR
    Participant

    Yes I was prolly a bit overpesimistic there. Everyting in Russia doesnt look hopelessly dark, just because democracy (or whatever one would like to call it) has started to take some worrying steps in the wrong direction as of lately. That, combined with a stagnation of the Russias econnomy, and a possible future resumed brain drain when the middle class have had enougth makes me feel pessimistic now and then these days.

    I hope Russia manage to keep these brilliant engineers that work on the carbon nanotube material. It would suck to se them accepting a ten fold paycheck increase and go and work for LM etc.

    And I hope there is a will from Sukhois side to consider this new research and if its found to be as important it well might be, there is a will to take the time to tast and implement it if possible. Even if it (probbably) would slow down the testing and production phase of the test aircraft. I.e trade time and monney now for a potential better end product in the future.

    Oh, and about Putin. IIRC he likes to babble alot about new weapons and when they will be going into active service in fantasy numbers whenever he gets a chance. Or has he stopped doing that?

    I think you dont know anything. Those who can do break through research they dont work for 10 fold paycheck. They want ownership in business or unlimited access to wealth/power.
    Without Arabian/Chinese dictatorship money. THere wont be EU but small states fighting each other. so i dont see EU style democracy even relevant to built gigantic long term military projects.

    see this example. the price of foreign football player.
    http://www.insidefutbol.com/2012/09/03/zenit-st-petersburg-stun-world-football-by-signing-chelsea-target-hulk/68339/

    I am sure Putin is going dump billions into Pak-FA to make it work.

    http://img88.imageshack.us/img88/6493/tdghernt5y4mn.jpg

    in reply to: China wants to make Su-35 clones? #2312750
    JSR
    Participant

    I didnot said any thing wrong with importing. some people get worked on when i made statement CHina will import heavy and high end aviation products for a very long time. No amount of R&D money or skilled manpower trained in West will solve it.
    In past 2.5 years. $4b worth of engines. if u put $5m per engine. these 800 total engines.

    http://www.ruaviation.com/news/2012/5/31/1037/
    During the last two and a half years China has acquired Russian engines to the amount of $4 billion; thanks to these contracts Salut has workload until 2015. It is expected that China will order more AL-31F engines in future (this refers to the high-powered modifications). At that the 140 ordered engines will have the increased thrust.

    China has some success in avionics and light weight UAVs but not some thing that can carry heavy stuff for long distance. Su-35/Su-34 come in that category.

    There is alot of products being developed in Russia for example like IL-476. Just China requirement alone will be 300 to 400 units. China will try to build some thing comparable but it will not work.
    IL-476 greater range, higher uptimes and speed make it more usefull to make direct flights from China to Africa with full protective gears against SAMs as IL-476 is going to be developed as Airrefueller and AWACS.

    http://4.bp.blogspot.com/-p9ED3kObyR4/TW6SJfYuF_I/AAAAAAAATkw/jicP-u9w3o8/s500/LIBYA%2BMARCH%2B2%252C%2B2011%2BDTN%2BNEWS%2B2.jpg

Viewing 15 posts - 3,601 through 3,615 (of 4,319 total)