dark light

halloweene

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 15 posts - 3,991 through 4,005 (of 4,136 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: F-35 debate thread. #2315824
    halloweene
    Participant

    Different roles warrant different requirements. It is not only LMA and the JSF program, but DOD that believes that manuverability is secondary to Stealth, Affordability, and Sensor reach and fusion when it comes to a Multi role fighter. They did not wish for TVC and also framed modest requirements. With the ATF they were required to come up with the most letal A2A fighter in the world , with the JSF the requirements are totally different.

    Affordability is the key word there :p
    Maybe one should add reliability (no bashing in this very sentence, hard start, w’ll see how it comes later)

    in reply to: What does JAS-39 offer over F/A-18 or F-16? #2315832
    halloweene
    Participant

    okay, concerns phase 2 evaluation made in 2009…
    But you are missing a point, if you look carefully at the bar. The comparison was done with Lot 4 (F3-04T) Rafale and P1E updated Typhoon…. Which will be obsolete when first Gripen NG will be delivered.:diablo:
    But thx for the info.

    in reply to: What does JAS-39 offer over F/A-18 or F-16? #2316428
    halloweene
    Participant

    … and that the final numbers were weighted by a credibility factor that was defined in 2008. ๐Ÿ˜‰

    i knew that but never saw the source, i am genuinely interested in.

    in reply to: What does JAS-39 offer over F/A-18 or F-16? #2316654
    halloweene
    Participant

    .. related to the systems fitted as Rii claimed before. ๐Ÿ˜‰

    Btw, time to remind that swiss eval (second stage) didnt concern present capabilities of planes, but the ones projected in 2015…

    in reply to: What does JAS-39 offer over F/A-18 or F-16? #2316933
    halloweene
    Participant

    4.5 gen.

    Lower RCS than the Typhoon, Rafale, F-16 and F/A-18 according to Canadian evaluations.

    No.

    Do you have source about the canadian evaluations please? i wouldnt be so surprised due to its smaller size, but i’m very interested in the evals you quote.

    halloweene
    Participant

    Yes, F-15E or Rafale would fit the bill,
    but the plan used to be to sell those F-18E back to USN once F-35 came.
    I now think the F-18 is permanent.
    F-18 is also cheaper to operate than F-15, which make a difference

    Thanks for sensible answers in an otherwise “hot” topic;)

    halloweene
    Participant

    /troll mode on

    They are training in ground to air missile shots

    /troll mode off

    halloweene
    Participant

    i’m just wondering, considering the huge size of Australia (and furthermore Canada), why stick to F18? Its range isnt that long. (F15, Rafale, Typhoon with CFT etc. got longer rangeno?)

    in reply to: What does JAS-39 offer over F/A-18 or F-16? #2317867
    halloweene
    Participant

    Why bring in Rafale and Typhoon? Want another flame debate?:eek:

    in reply to: Dassault Rafale #14 – News & Discussion #2318637
    halloweene
    Participant

    http://www.tacticalreport.com/view_product/libya/24

    Libya, France, airbases and Mirage fighter jets (30 credits)
    Posted on: Wed, Feb 27, 2013

    The Libyan Defence Ministry is said to have received a French proposal described as โ€œencouragingโ€ for it to go ahead with its contacts with France to buy Mirage fighter jets. The following 404-word report sheds light on the subject and tells what about the French proposal and tells what about the contacts between Libya and France on a deal for the Mirage and on which type.

    in reply to: Dassault Rafale #14 – News & Discussion #2319071
    halloweene
    Participant

    It is becomming a recurrent rumour… Maybe something serious behind the scene?

    in reply to: F35 News only thread for 2013 #2319076
    halloweene
    Participant

    “The Pentagon program chief for the F-35 warplane slammed its commercial partners Lockheed Martin and Pratt & Whitney on Wednesday, accusing them of trying to “squeeze every nickel” out of the U.S. government and failing to see the long-term benefits of the project.

    U.S. Lieutenant-General Christopher Bogdan made the comments during a visit to Australia, where he has sought to convince lawmakers and generals to stick to a plan to buy 100 of the jets, an exercise complicated by the second grounding of the plane this year and looming U.S. defence cuts.”

    http://www.defense-aerospace.com/articles-view/release/3/143023/f_35-program-chief-slams-lockheed%2C-pratt.html

    His comments about LM and P&W may not be the best argument to persuade Australia to stick to its commitment to F-35 but they are refreshingly candid.

    Ouch ๐Ÿ˜ฎ

    in reply to: Indian Missiles News #1790653
    halloweene
    Participant

    Its all a bunch of excuses.

    Take a look at this forum itself & say Scorpion82’s posts on Eurofighter. They are better than 90% of the EF reportage out there. And this is a so called “amateur” as versus a professional defense journalist. If he had that routine access & did it full time, his quality of work would dwarf all the lengthy articles in the expensive trade mags.

    The amount of information here:http://rafale.freeforums.org/

    Is far in excess of what appears in most of the world’s media, bar the rare article which is well sourced & sufficiently detailed.

    At the end of the day, its all about sincerity.

    There are far too many “professional journalists” who are going around posturing as experts in a field they don’t either care about, or just treat as yet another job

    I both know Tmor and Scorpion, and regularly talk with them (via forum) ๐Ÿ˜Ž

    And i know they are very reliable and knowledgable sources (in fact i very recently asked Scorpion where to find a comprehensive summary of Eurofighter evolutions). Aswell as some others. But what Merurius pointed is that journalist cannot be as specialized as they are… And i intended to quote myself as an amateur…
    If you like as uch as i do Tmor site, you may also find those two sites interesting : http://rafalefan.e-monsite.com/blog/7/
    http://rafalenews.blogspot.fr/

    Have a nice day!

    in reply to: Indian Missiles News #1790667
    halloweene
    Participant

    Of course critcs are easy. “Art is dufficult, critcs is easy”. But doese it in anyway exonerate responsability to written words?
    I am in no way trying to point at anyone/any profession. But what you are saying is that either journalists are not numerous enough, either not competent (due to lack of specialization?) enough.
    In the end, who are we (amateurs) meant to trust?

    in reply to: F35 News only thread for 2013 #2319452
    halloweene
    Participant

    I see one missing (not only nationalistic feeling) : ASTER and folloing your point, THADD had a 100% hit percentage after first attempts…

Viewing 15 posts - 3,991 through 4,005 (of 4,136 total)