dark light

MiG-23MLD

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 15 posts - 2,701 through 2,715 (of 2,930 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: F-22A Raptor's Impressive Kill Ratio #2574837
    MiG-23MLD
    Participant

    Another source F-22: Super Stealth, super fast, super costlyLANGLEY AIR FORCE BASE, Va. – The gold-tinted canopy closed and a wave of apprehension swept over Air Force pilot Wade Tolliver as he started the jet engines for his first flight in an F-22 Raptor. RELATED
    Multimedia

    The mission: Air dominance

    ” I was scared I’d scratch the jet,” Tolliver said.
    The lieutenant colonel, a veteran of more than 2,000 hours in jets, had reason to worry. A mistake could be very costly. The plane he sat in cost $339 million.

    The Raptor is the Air Force’s new

    source http://www.timesdispatch.com/servlet/Satellite?pagename=RTD/MGArticle/RTD_BasicArticle&c=MGArticle&cid=1137834444308

    in reply to: F-22A Raptor's Impressive Kill Ratio #2574850
    MiG-23MLD
    Participant

    Again the contract is for a batch of F-22 to be located with a particular wing. When India buys the su-30MKI there is a cost invloved which is required to get indian AF ready for the su-30MKI such as maintance equipment,technical modifications etc etc. What you are using as reference is a contracted ammount interms of a yearly contract which isnt the right thing to go by . If you are willing to search then go see the Congressional testimonies of AF officials where they break up those costs. Try to find some C – SPAN footage on the net which addresses these concerns.

    check this other estimate:

    Of that $541 billion, Speeter sharply criticized the federal government for spending $72 billion on buying what he called outdated Cold War weapons such as a $260 millon F-22 fighter jet.

    source http://www.yaledailynews.com/articlefunctions/Printerfriendly.asp?AID=28458

    not USD $100 millions but USD $260

    see this other

    F-22 Raptor—Program costs increased 2.1 percent from $61.3 billion to $62.6 billion, because of the purchase of four additional aircraft, extension of procurement to Fiscal 2012, and increases in initial spares buys.
    source http://www.afa.org/magazine/June2006/0606world.asp

    in reply to: F-22A Raptor's Impressive Kill Ratio #2574855
    MiG-23MLD
    Participant

    Raptors are being built for around $100 million USD right now. That’s due, according to Lockheed, to changes in the manufacturing process. The first couple of batches of Raptors were way expensive, sure; that’s because the development costs were spread over those early batches as they were the only solid orders on the books at the time.

    The fixed price is USD $187 million see

    According to Pentagon budget documents, the F-22 Raptor program’s FY 2006 budget is $4.22 bilion (FY05: $4.62 billion), in return for 24 production F-22As and 1 test aircraft (FY05: 24/0). The procurement budget is $3.77 billion (FY05: $4.09 billion), and the RDT&E budget is $448.2 million (FY05: $530.2 million).
    4620 millions divided by 25 gives you a fixed price of 187 millions a piece

    however the price continues scalating June 15/06: A $187.1 million firm-fixed-price contract modification to provide for an extension to the advance buy period of performance from June 2006 through September 2006, and increases the outlay amount. This action supports F-22A Lot 7 production. Work will be performed at Lockheed Martin Aeronautics Co. in Marietta, GA (33%) and Fort Worth, TX (35%); and Boeing Information and Space Defense Systems, Aircraft and Missile Systems group in Seattle, WA (32%). Work will be complete in October 2009 (FA8611-06-C-2899/P00005)

    source http://www.defenseindustrydaily.com/2006/06/f22-raptor-fy-2006-procurement-events-updated/index.php

    another stimate

    Of that $541 billion, Speeter sharply criticized the federal government for spending $72 billion on buying what he called outdated Cold War weapons such as a $260 millon F-22 fighter jet.

    source http://www.yaledailynews.com/articlefunctions/Printerfriendly.asp?AID=28458

    in reply to: F-22A Raptor's Impressive Kill Ratio #2574872
    MiG-23MLD
    Participant

    Raptors are being built for around $100 million USD right now. That’s due, according to Lockheed, to changes in the manufacturing process. The first couple of batches of Raptors were way expensive, sure; that’s because the development costs were spread over those early batches as they were the only solid orders on the books at the time.

    so why they reduced the numbers? the 100 million price is not correct because you have to pay for development costs and reduced numbers means unaffordability

    in reply to: F-22A Raptor's Impressive Kill Ratio #2574883
    MiG-23MLD
    Participant

    The raptor’s cost is put at above 300 million if you take into account the development however when we are comparing attrition then the fighters development cost becomes non-redundant so its only fly-away therefore the price of 100-110 million a peice is more acurate in this scenario as it is more representative of the flyaway cost..You can PM Harry ,or some other Indian members and ask them how they came up with the 50 million of the Su-30MKI which also BTW include western harware aswell. The su-35 isnt in serial production so the Russian sources that put 38-40 million arent based on an actual calculation of an actual existing production line for the Su-35 and therefore is what the russians expect it to come out to same as the USAF expected the raptor to come out to 60 million a pop however the russians should do better as things are cheaper there. Even if we take 40 million for the su-35 and 100 million for the raptor it is only slighgly more then 2.5 Su-35’s per F-22A and not 10:1 that you were saying.

    To put it at a 1:4 level the su-30MKI would need to cost 20-25 million dollars which I think is highly unacheivable.

    Again there have been statements made before about it flying,about it being cancelled,about a single PAKFA,about 2 aircrafts , About India wanting to join and nothing really has come out as concrete fact . Meanwhile the F-22 is flying and the F-35 is being slowly but surely being put into place as is evident from the pics and videos LMA releases evry 14 days to show progress.

    Please bring_it_on

    you calculations are totally overboard, let`s see why?

    You claim a 100 million price for an aircraft that is built in lesser numbers than planned.

    The F-22 cost of more than 300 millions is the correct because some one has to pay for the development and that is the US Tax payer, that money has to be paid.

    You are claiming the F-22 cost almost as much as the Eurofighter but the numbers the US buys are more than three times less :rolleyes:

    Europe builds more than four times more Typhoons and Rafales and you give a price tag of 100 million for an aircraft that less than 200 will be built, like if the military cuts do not make more expensive the aircraft! :rolleyes:

    Consider the European military budget combined is much more smaller than the US` and remeber only five nations are buying Eurofighters and Rafales in large numbers.

    If they have reduced the numbers is because the aircraft is too expensive 😉

    in reply to: F-22A Raptor's Impressive Kill Ratio #2574911
    MiG-23MLD
    Participant

    “Harry” who I consider to be one of the most educated source on the Su-30MKI puts it at 50-55 million for the Su-30MKI flyaway which would make it only about 1/2 the price of the raptors Flyaway so in a war of attrition the raptor ‘s cost would be 2:1 in favour of the Su-30MKI.

    Again you are comparing what is expected and might happed to what allready exists and are giving them equal weightage, We have been hearing timeframes about the PAKFA and what not for years now so I wont believe that it exists until it flies or atleast we see one being assembled. Excuse me If you think I am rude but I’ve been hearing about this for years and I see reports in Russian press and some in Western press but nothing is concrete so Deal with what exists today.

    With airframes , engines yes I’d agree but what about avionics , weapons systems etc etc the MKI has a lot of systems that are non-russian did the russians planned for those on the Su-37??

    Bring_it_on

    Russian sources put the price of a Su-35 in the range of 30-38 million dollars and the price of a F-22 in the minimun of 100 dollars and even claim 400 million dollars.

    I have read 200 millions a piece for a F-22, i think an F-22 costs at least 200 dollars and i think the Russians sources are not wrong why?

    The Europeans having an economy as big as the US can buy more than 800 Eurofighters and Rafales having an smaller military budget.

    The Russian labour cost is also cheaper, to put it in terms costs Russia is a cheap nation to manufacture so a Su-30MKI should be cheaper than a Eurofighter or Rafale and much much cheaper than an F-22 at least in a 1:7 ratio

    The Su-30MKI is a Eurofighter class fighter not a F-22 so it must be also cheaper than the I-21.

    If we take the Russian air force and Sukhoi statements the PAK FA or I-21 is now being built in one of Sukhoi`s plants

    in reply to: F-22A Raptor's Impressive Kill Ratio #2574946
    MiG-23MLD
    Participant

    I have been saying this all Along and the pilots themselves (raptor drivers) Know this and this is the sole reason why the F-22 has TVC and Is in the process of getting HMD and HOBS. Once it gets that then everything is even and we are left with an ugly ugly situation of 2 very expensive fighters (raptor and PAKFA) going at each other with no certainity of who will finish on top. That is the essence of top quality WVR . You can be near perfect but when the odds are like that (raptor vs Su-30) the outcome might still be against you. That is why WVR has to be avoided to get better kill ratios. I think you’ll agree to this.

    That is interesting was the Su-37 ever planned to have French,indian and Iserili avionics and weapons???

    For sure the su-30MKI coupled with the IAF pilots is the best of the best. A real benchmark for everyone else to stack up against as far as WVR is concerned.

    When you get into that region everything changes. The raptor would also be accompanied by E-8’s and Dedicated jamming aircraft such as E-18’s and that combination of overwhelming support that the USAF/USN can throw at the opponent is unmatched.

    Bring_it_on

    The Su-30MKI and Su-37 are the same aircraft, the Sukhoi`s terminology and nomenclature makes it little bit difficult but in essence the Su-37 and Su-30MKI are T-10M subvariants and all are called Flankers.

    http://www.airwar.ru/image/idop/fighter/su30mki/su30mki-9.jpg
    See the fact both aircraft have canards and thrust vectoring, both are T-10M subvariants
    compare http://www.airwar.ru/image/idop/fighter/su37/su37-5.jpg

    These two aircraft are the same aircraft with the only difference of nomenclature and the real fact one is a single seat and the other is a twin seat the same as the F-15C and the F-15E

    picture source http://www.airwar.ru/fighternow.html

    in reply to: F-22A Raptor's Impressive Kill Ratio #2574951
    MiG-23MLD
    Participant

    Who cares? Odds are your non-existent Su-35s and Mig-29OVTs will be flamming comets of scrap metal before they even know there’s an F-22 around. I’ll grant you you’re as tenacious as Firebar but how about waking up to reality?

    In fact you are saying something true, it is very likely the Su-30MKI or MiG-29OVT will be shot down at least in a rate of 10:1 or more, however see these two points:

    A) The Chinese and Russians are working in anti-stealth technologies, one F-117 was shot down by a SAM made in the 1960s, according to Chinese and Russian statements stealth aircraft are detectable and there is a very likely possibility they can get better radars and detection systems to track the F-22

    If the Chinese or Russians succed in getting systems that can detect the F-22 well believe me a Su-30MKI will come very handy specially because it cost 10 times less

    B)The Russians will fly a stealth fighter in the 2007-2009 time frame so the gap will be closed and the Russians are building F-22 and F-35 counterparts, India is involved in the F-35 counterpart

    in reply to: F-22A Raptor's Impressive Kill Ratio #2574975
    MiG-23MLD
    Participant

    Yes and I being of indian origin (half indian) and a keen follower of IAF would know this!! So whats yur point???

    And How would your Su-35BM be superior to the F-22A…Please state yur point a little carefully.

    This has been discussed to death months ago and alert 5 even has pilots from the USN and USAF discussing this. Also go read up on the F-16.net for more information. My source on this is a pilot who isone of the most senior F-22 pilots and he said that there are actually 6 HUD shots that he has seen of f-18’s , F-16’s and F-15’s killing Raptor in dogfights so it isnt a big deal, He also has some 40 odd HUD images F-22’s gunning all these jets down. He is really impressed how the raptor compares with these fighters in dogfighting and love it to death and cant wait for them to get HMD’s and 9x and be at par with the best in the WVR buisness .

    Again How is your Su-35 going to be better in BVR,signature,detection,avionics,supercruise and in time (another 3 years ) the F-22A would have taken care of its shortcommings in WVR ie. lack of HMD/HOBS.

    Bring_it_on

    I am aware the F-22 is at this moment the best overall fighter, nevertheless the Su-35 and MiG-29OVT at dogfight are not easy targets, there is one thing we have to say this, any fighter with thrust vectoring nozzles, HMS and advanced missiles has chances against the F-22 at within visuall range combat.

    The Su-35UB is basicly a Su-30MKI, the Su-30MKI is an equivalent of the Su-37.

    If you have a Su-30MKI, it is in fact a twin seat Su-37.

    A HMS gives you the ability of overcome maneouvrability shortcomings, nevertheless the Su-30MKI has good agility and good missiles.

    My opinion about the effectiveness of the F-22 is only rules in BVR combat but if i were a F-22 pilot i would avoid a dogfight with a Su-30MKI, why? because it can shoot me down.
    http://www.airwar.ru/image/idop/fighter/su35ub/su35ub-6.jpg
    At very shot range the Su-30MKI has an IRST system, good agility, a HMS, good missiles and thrust vectoring so it is not inferior in agility and in dogfight combat capability.

    In BVR combat well that is different, the Su-30MKI has disadvantages that only the I-21 can fix.

    in reply to: F-22A Raptor's Impressive Kill Ratio #2575454
    MiG-23MLD
    Participant

    Flex, I’d swear it seems to actually bother you that the USAF wants more than it’s fair share of F-22’s?

    Why do you care so much how many we have? Are you going to be fussing about the numbers of F-35’s ordered in the coming years?

    Your question as to why we need the numbers we do has been answered time and again and yet you continue to ignore the responses. What’s wrong with you?

    China? You even answered why F-22’s would be necessary..or one of the reasons. If China does invade Taiwan you can bet they won’t get a warm reception, and I’m not just talking about the ROCAF fighting them……..as in U.S. CVBG’s and land-based bombers and fighters (including the F-22 which will clear the sky of any PLAAF or PLAN fighter with little trouble) to take on the communists and help the Taiwanese out.

    There’s also that whole thing about the F-15 fleet getting old and expensive to maintain. They’ve got to be replaced. Do we just keep them flying until they fall out of the air one by one? Do we just buy new F-15’s that have clearly been shown to be inferior to an aircraft like a well-equipped Su-30MKI? No.

    The answer is the F-22, and if you don’t have enough to cover your air defense needs as well as your potential expeditionary needs then you’ve made a pointless purchase. I realize you’d like the United States to go into isolationism again and quit terrorizing the world, but the truth of the matter is that expeditionary forces are now the norm and issues like China, North Korea, and Iran will always be monitored and acted on if necessary. I’m currently learned about modern USAF doctrine in a class I’m taking as a new Lt., and I have to come to grips with the fact that I will be deployed many times in my career. It’s not a question of if, but when. Thus, aircraft like the F-22 (and F-35) are required to meet the changing needs and upcoming threats of the future. The F-22 and F-35 will ensure that we can stay ahead of the competition for quite some time.

    MiG-23MLD,
    When those Su-35’s start pouring off the production lines you be sure and let me know. That way I can come visit your planet to see what an operational combat ready Su-35 looks like. I’m pretty sure here on planet Earth you won’t see any. 🙂

    Phantom II

    The list of aircraft the Russian air force will recieve in 2006 its the following Mi-28, Su-34 and Yak-130, besides they are continuing the modernization of aircraft like the Su-27, Su-24 and MiG-29, this was said by the Russian General Vladimir Mihailov

    Here is the source in Russian

    В 2006 году ВВС РФ получит на вооружение новые самолеты Су-34 и вертолеты Ми-28, сообщает РИА Новости. Об этом заявил на пресс-конференции главнокомандующий ВВС России, генерал армии Владимир Михайлов.главнокомандующий ВВС России, генерал армии Владимир Михайлов.

    “В 2006 году ВВС РФ получит не только модернизированные машины, но и новые летательные аппараты, такие, как самолет Су-34 и вертолет Ми-28. Кроме того, в конце года к нам поступит самолет Як-130”, – сказал Михайлов.

    Генерал также рассказал о том, что в настоящее время продолжается модернизация самолетов Су-27, Су-24 и Су-25. “Мы активно занимаемся модернизацией самолетов МиГ-29 и МиГ-31

    Check already the Su-34 is in the list, the Su-35 is expected by 2007-2009 time frame.

    Source http://lenta.ru/news/2006/01/17/glavkom/

    here is the information for the Su-35 production:

    Ярославский “Сатурн” будет делать двигатель для Су-35 Рыбинское предприятие НПО “Сатурн”, занимающееся разработкой и выпуском авиационных двигателей, подписало договор с ОАО “Авиационная холдинговая компания Сухой” и ОАО “УМПО”. Цель договора – разработка и запуск в серийное производство авиационного двигателя “117С”, предназначенного для самолета Су-35.
    Как сообщает корреспондент REGIONS.RU, разработку силовой установки “117С” планируют закончить к 2008 году, чтобы в 2009 приступить к серийному производству

    here you see they already signed an agreement bewteen Saturn and Sukhoi to fit the Su-35 with the newest 117 engines, these engines will start production in 2009.

    See they claim they will be for export Su-35s
    Самолеты Су-35, на которые будут устанавливаться новые двигатели, ориентированы прежде всего на экспорт.

    Source http://www.regions.ru/news/transport/1985601/

    in reply to: F-22A Raptor's Impressive Kill Ratio #2575468
    MiG-23MLD
    Participant

    Found this few minutes ago:
    http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v255/nc_creeper/F18FGUNF-2203.jpg
    “It had to happen some day. I guess the pilot of this Super Bug is pretty proud of himself. Here are two HUD captures from a VFA-11 F/A-18F acting as Red Air against an F-22A
    Looks like the Raptor found himself in front of a slow Super Hornet, which is not where anybody wants to be. The F-18F is at 15K feet, 20 degrees AOA, Mach 0.36, pulling 1.7G, with a peak previous G of 7.6 for the fight. HUD shows he has squeezed the trigger. It’s not exactly what you’d call “comfortably saddled up in his six” or anything like that — it’s clearly a high deflection shot — but it does show the Super Hornet can point its nose when it wants to.”

    That is a Super Hornet however the Su-35 must be better here is a report about the fact Sukhoi plans to start production of the Su-35 in 2006 according to Mihail Pogosyan Head chief of Sukhoi.

    here is the article:Российский самолетостроительный холдинг “Сухой” планирует начать производство опытных образцов самолета Су-35 в 2006 году, сообщает “Интерфакс”.

    he claims it will be build at Konsomolsk on amur (KnAAPO)

    Самолеты будут строиться на Комсомольском-на-Амуре авиационно-производственном объединении им. Гагарина (КнААПО).

    These will be for the Russian Air Force and by 2009 they will be ready for export

    sourcehttp://lenta.ru/news/2005/10/04/su35/

    Here is the original source from the official Sukhoi company webpage

    http://www.sukhoi.org/news/smi/?id=398

    in reply to: F-22A Raptor's Impressive Kill Ratio #2575519
    MiG-23MLD
    Participant

    No we where swapping maintenance and operator stories about a US built SA-3 Goa simulator (His kit) and a Real SA-8 Gecko (My kit) in a bar at the time. 😀

    Shshshs it is a secret do not tell any one, shush shush :rolleyes: they shot down a F-117 shush because we were drunk shush and the pilot was watching the buggs bunny show in his watchman when he was shot down :rolleyes:

    Sources: classified 😀

    in reply to: F-22A Raptor's Impressive Kill Ratio #2575524
    MiG-23MLD
    Participant

    That F-117 Shoot Down in 1999 was a fluke, believe me (I do have sources a lot more reliable than AFM speculation and doggy Russian web sites, unfortunately for all you F-117 lovers I cannot tell the whole story thanks to my sources still being classified).

    Yes they are classified so your sources are not not doggy? hehehehehehe

    in reply to: F-22A Raptor's Impressive Kill Ratio #2575527
    MiG-23MLD
    Participant

    How dare you!!!!

    However the F-117 winged peice was stolen and taken to a top secret location in Russia where they were able to micro-multiply it and came up with hoards of F-117 types of aircraft and handed them onto the Chinese for aproximately 200 IBM’s per aircraft which were then used to test chinese defences on and later compulate that the defences would take aprox 30 seconds to shoot down a F-22A in aproximately 789 days after the raptor IOC and this information was secretly obtained by the Indians who used it to order a particular varient of the Mig-29 . So in reality if the F-117 would have never been shot down there would have been No Mig-29OVT. Ofcourse your biased source didnt tell you all this.

    Bring_it_on

    There is nantion you have forgeten today is recieving Su-30MKI in regular basis: named India and will have several dozen of those in 2009, there is a chance also will recieve MiG-29OVT and i think also can fire Python IV and if i am not wrong recieves Python IV, yes, yes, it is India!

    flukes do not happen, flukes are excuses, yes it is a very confortable way to call a defeat, the only way to hide a humilated ego.

    Wait 2 years and you will see the I-21 or reports of the first flight of the Russian I-21, besides you will see the induction of Su-35BM into the Russian air Force

    in reply to: F-22A Raptor's Impressive Kill Ratio #2575695
    MiG-23MLD
    Participant

    YEs at the moment the F-22A doesnt have HMS however it is a spiral prgram and they made a descision to not use the JHMCS and use the more advanced JSF-HMD which pushed the integration by 2 years and brought it into conflict witht he SDB integration which got the preference so the HMD integration is due in 2008-09. In tests against HMS equiped F-18’s and F-16’s the F-22A has been less impressive but we only have to wait 3 years to see that sorted out.

    Yeah the russians have TVC for a long time and even have a operational fighter with it which was the first however U were talking about TVC equiped J-10’s and I’ve yet to see one in operation where as i see a scores of TVC equiped raptors in operation.

    By the time there’s a Mig-29OVT armed with the R-74 in operation with substantial no.s the raptor would have long perfected tactics on TVC/HMS/HOBS usage.

    The reason why I support the raptor is because the enemy has gotten better and we need to take that extra step to regain the advantage..

    Yes they do have successes at a higher rate then the ones With F-15’s w/o HMS. Mostly F-16’s and F18’s simulate HMS and 9x and they have been succesfull that is why the raptor is getting HMD.

    Again when its HARD FACTS vs SPECULATION ” I and many other logical people would choose the former to the latter.

    No it is not expeculation, a F-117 shot down by a second rated air force that had inferiority in numbers and equipment, RAM wing fragments sent to Russia, the physics of STEALTH FIRST PUBLISHED IN RUSSIA BY A RUSSIAN SCIENTISTS, and statements of the Russian air force to fly their fifth generation in one year time. A Czech radar claimed to detect stealth aircraft and 3D engines made in Russia for the Indian perpective order of MiG-35.

Viewing 15 posts - 2,701 through 2,715 (of 2,930 total)