dark light

MiG-23MLD

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 15 posts - 811 through 825 (of 2,930 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: Argentina and Brazil to develop nuclear submarine #2090063
    MiG-23MLD
    Participant

    😀

    Go and try to tell that to the Brazilians… A South American Army with… Chavez Venezuela, and Argentina?!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
    The two biggest Brazilian defense foruns are “forum defesa Brazil” and “Alide”, try to write something like that in there and you´re going to get “stoned”. You can find several officers of the Brazilian armed forces there and, believe me, the chances of that “South American Army” happening in the next two decades are slightly bigger (but just slightly) of Iran recieving an invitation to join NATO.
    Dont mix Hugo Chavez dreams with reality.

    Man do not make me laugh, in Latin america there are many opinions some are totally contradictory, however a forum does not make policies, The governments of Brazil and Argentina along side the ones of Mercosur have a regional plan of economic integration and eventually an economic plan of a common currency and movement freely of goods and people within the MERCOSUR nations this will imply at the end a common military plan, you might think a forum decides policies but it does not policies are taken by Lula and his advisors and all the heads of states of South america and they know economic integration will mean political integration and this will lead to a common defence.

    in reply to: Argentina and Brazil to develop nuclear submarine #2090124
    MiG-23MLD
    Participant

    Ok, so I guess there is no military block.

    There is a project to create a single nation based upon the Mercosur, this has already started building a basic frame of military cooperation, Argentina is starting to build weaponry with Brazil as a partner and Hugo Chavez is asking for the creation of a Cuban, Venezuelan, Bolivian and Nicaraguan military pact.

    Os dois mais poderosos exércitos do Brasil e da Argentina uniram esforços para desenvolver uma nova viatura leve para ser adotada principalmente por suas unidades para-quedistas. Denominado “Gaúcho”, o segundo protótipo do veículo foi apresentado recentemente na Argentina e se espera que uma encomenda para a produção do modelo ocorra em breve. Clicando aqui você poderá ler um pouco mais sobre o veículo e baixar um vídeo com o mesmo.

    This article talks about this simple Jeep developed by Brazil and Argentina and will be produced for the armies of both nations in a joint venture

    http://www.defesanet.com.br/imagens/eb/vtr_leve/gaucho_1.jpg

    http://para-quedas.blogspot.com/2006_06_01_archive.html

    HUGO CHAVEZ CALLS FOR DEFENSE PACT BETWEEN VENEZUELA, CUBA, NICARAGUA, BOLIVIA
    President Chavez called for the creation of a common defense.

    President Hugo Chavez called for the creation of a common defense pact between Venezuela, Cuba, Nicaragua and Bolivia, while the Latin American bloc announced the creation of a development bank to finance joint projects.

    Chavez said Wednesday that the four-nation Bolivarian Alternative for the Americas, or ALBA, which began as a socialist-leaning trade group, should cooperate militarily to become more independent of U.S. influence.

    http://www.gkcaracas.um.dk/da/menu/Eksportraadgivning/Markedsmuligheder/SidsteNyt/HugoChavezCallsForDefensePactBetweenVenezuelaCubaNicaraguaBolivia.htm

    in reply to: Argentina and Brazil to develop nuclear submarine #2090130
    MiG-23MLD
    Participant

    I gathered you wanted independence from west? Is france different or trusted? After all france did help british nullify exocets. If all you need is license production then yes money is the only hindrance.

    No one has said in Latin america we do not recieve technical advise or help but one of the goals is to be independent or in few words create the technology by our selves once we have learnt adn gotten the tech transfers.

    The SCORPENE submarine is a tech transfer but it will help Brazil to develop a submarine

    in reply to: Argentina and Brazil to develop nuclear submarine #2090170
    MiG-23MLD
    Participant

    Yes they could buy them off the shelf but then they should shut up about being independent of the west :rolleyes: . It is not DRDO’s arrogance that GTRE is a big f**k up. If you don’t have a clue about why India went with Lockheed and not the French just say so. There are enough people on BR who will enlighten you. By your standards even pakistan has a fighter, kudos to them.

    Man you misunderstand a lot Latin america, in fact one of the first persons to have ever flown was a Brazilian, Santos Dumont, Argentina was one of the first jet makers in the world, since the early 1920s Mexico, Brazil and Argentina had aircraft built locally, so then why only Brazil has succeed?

    Number one is Brazil has chosen the right partner:France
    Number two Brazil has made civil aircraft that do make profit and number three Brazil takes technology transfers from nations willing to do it and does not depend upon a single partner has diversified its partners

    Argentina is not different is probable that if Argentina would had followed the right policies they could have now a nuclear submarine and several jet fighters even balistic missiles.

    The Bombi an aircraft designed in argentina
    http://magazineaereo.blogspot.com/2007/08/aviones-de-la-fma.html
    In Latin America the wrog policies have slowdown the development, this has send many latin american scientists to work over seas and the unwillingness of some potential partners to transfer technology has also slow down the very limited budgets of latin american military programs.

    The reason you have not seen real military programs in Latin american is simply because there has not been willingness and a jet engine is also a technology not impossible to adquire however without the right policies and economic benefits it is impossible to get it.

    In few words Latin america can build fighters however the unwilligness of past governments have dented the capability to do it and many nations do not see a real economic benefit in doing so.

    in reply to: J-10 vs J-11 #2494658
    MiG-23MLD
    Participant

    Here we have different data for the J-10
    Its length is 16.5 meters, wing span 9.36 Wing area of 34.6 square meters.
    Empty weight of 8300 kg and Max take off weight 18000kg a normal take off of 11500kg armed with two PL-12 and two PL-8, a range of 2300km on internal fuel only and max range of 2900km with fuel tanks and a max ceiling of 18000.

    A max speed of Mach 2.2

    http://www.airwar.ru/other/draw2/j10aiv.html

    in reply to: Argentina and Brazil to develop nuclear submarine #2090341
    MiG-23MLD
    Participant

    One of the most remarkable products offered by INVAP is the only power station wholly designed in Argentina, the CAREM, a small 27,5 MW plant. This is a third generation or “inherently-safe” station, which may also be designed of a larger size (up to 350 MW apiece). Furthermore, CAREM is modular: several similar units may be coupled to add power. The construction of a first prototype on Argentine soil remains a pending issue to the nation.

    The reward for the completion of such issue could prove to be substantial. If research reactors represent a side niche within the nuclear market, power stations are its heart. Only a handful of small reactors were sold throughout the world during the 1990s, but there are 36 power stations under construction to date, and for sums that are incomparably higher.

    The CAREM is the only Argentine answer to this huge market. Although its revolutionarily simple and safe design is already being copied by companies from Japan, South Korea, and the US, the Argentine supply remains more viable than its imitations because our project is more developed.

    The export potential for CAREM has been conservatively estimated between 4 to 20 units, which for Argentina would mean cashing from 400 million to 2 billion dollars, and the creation of a new niche of its own in the nuclear station market.

    this reactor is what according to argentine reports will be the basis for the nuclear reactor submarine

    http://www.invap.net/nuclear/index-e.html

    http://www.savoiapower.com/Images/nuclear1.gif

    CNEA and its associated company INVAP, have developped the CAREM project: a low power nuclear plant (100 MWth, 25 MWe net), conceived with a new generation, innovative design.
    -The CAREM NPP has a pressurized water reactor with several steam generators, whose characteristics make it different:

    * integrated and self pressurized primary system cooling by natural circulation

    *passive safety systems

    *no plant requirments of Diesel emergency electric generators

    * plant control performed by a distributed software system

    Safety enhancement is basically the result of two facts:
    – many events that would lead to accidental conditions are rendered impossible by the innovative design

    http://www.savoiapower.com/nuclear.html

    in reply to: Argentina and Brazil to develop nuclear submarine #2090388
    MiG-23MLD
    Participant

    NO but for SA to form the kind of block you are suggesting. They would have to be able to develop these things independently. Else they still dependent on others.

    Broncho in today`s world tech transfers need to occur, undoutedly Latin american and South America in general are still places with medium development indexes and some countries are too poor, the region has probably the world`s worst inequality between poor and rich.

    however your assertion that developed nations developed everything by their own is not acurate, Argentina and Brazil are nations of immigrants too and do have talented scientists that is the reason Argentina has a mini reactor called CAREM and Brazil can start developing a nuclear submarine, for South America developing its own technology is not as you think an impossibility to the contrary it is already a fact, besides Argentina and Brazil have large european immigrant populations that do deal with Europe and get tech transfers, however the difference is now Argentina and Brazil want to protect the local markets and resources, the Osorio, TAM, Pulqui were not designed by a single person or a foreign company as you claim they were cooproductions or simple a recenlty landed immigrant like in the US Werner Von Braun or Sikorsky lead the project.

    The Current Submarine will have some French help but it does not mean a great part of the nuclear submarine can not be produced locally

    Este mes, el presidente francés Nicolas Sarkozy dijo que Francia buscaba transferir a Brasil la tecnología necesaria para fabricar un submarino militar convencional Scorpene.

    Brasil sostiene que utilizará el Scorpene como modelo para desarrollar su submarino nuclear, que sería el primero en América Latina.

    According to this the French President Nicolas Sarkosy said the France wanted to transfer the Scoppene Submarine technology to Brazil.

    Brazil wants to develop the nuclear submarine based upon the Scorpene technology

    source http://ar.news.yahoo.com/s/ap/080225/internacionales/ams_gen_brasil_argentina_nuclear

    in reply to: Argentina and Brazil to develop nuclear submarine #2090395
    MiG-23MLD
    Participant

    TAM was designed by German Thyssen-Henschel and the IAe.27 Pulqui I by french man Émile Dewoitine and IAe.33 Pulqui II by kurt tank. The osorio seems intersting but sad it went under. Once again were the powerplants for any of these built by SA nations or were they simply bouht from europe? The Ch-14 on the otherhand seems wholly made in argentia?

    Man the Nuclear weapon in the US was developed by European scientist, Einstein, Openhiemer, Edward Teller, the helicopter by a russian Igor Sikorsky, the AC by Nicola Testla and the space program lead by a Nazi named Werner Von Braun so what?

    What you are trying to say there is no local ingenuity in South America, but that is far from the truth in fact the US takes lots of Latin american scientists each year, however in the modern world Latin american still needs tech transfers but definitively the local industries are getting knowledge to build things domestically and a good example is Embraer.

    In fact many American or European companies have research centers in latin american G&E for example designs some jet engine control systems in Mexico these are designed by mexican engineers, what is really happening now is in Latin america the South american nations have realized that they can build the same technology locally and for domestic companies

    in reply to: Argentina and Brazil to develop nuclear submarine #2090424
    MiG-23MLD
    Participant

    NATO is an expeditionary force. I am sorry but I can agree that SA nations can form a collective defense pact but I do not see them able to project power outwards like NATO. Even collectively their economies cannot sustain more than 3 carriers. EU on the other hand will soon have 7 carriers and they can easily afford them.
    What do you mean idependent from foriegn powers? Brazil is already a progressive economy and important BRIC member. It has the resources to develop on its own. Mercosur seems like a trade block not a defence pact that you seem to envisage.

    Brazil and Argentina understand that the main weakness of South america has been its political fragmentation, since Bolivar to the Che Guevara years the idea of an united Latin America has been brewing up, however under the current economic integretion that international economic trade has been nurturing, the Bolivarian dream is at reach.

    Argentina has had a history of military achievenments that many times have been forgotten, for example Argentian developed jet fighters before even India or China, Argentina and Brazil developed tanks, the Osorio and Tanque mediano Argentino, however all of this needs a larger budget and only upon economic integration can it be achieved in the same way in Europe they developed programs like the Tornado or Airbus

    Here we see the Tanque Mediano Argentino TAM
    http://www.defesanet.com.br/imagens/argentina/tam.jpg

    the Osorio main battle tank

    http://www.fprado.com/armorsite/Osorio-Pics/Osorio-MBT.jpg

    Argentina`s first fighter jet

    http://www.machtres.com/puldos01.jpg

    here is some of the history of the first rocket launches in Peru and Mexico so you can se one of the main weakness of Latin america is been the lack of cooperation in the past

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AEdpahrKW0M&feature=related

    in reply to: Argentina and Brazil to develop nuclear submarine #2090443
    MiG-23MLD
    Participant

    If they have learned the right lessons from the Falklands war they will procure a powerful submarine force before they get a carrier.

    The Nuclear submarine project is older than many think, Argentina offered Brazil after the Falklands war the plan of developing a nuclear subamrine to close the tech gap with England

    Tras la Guerra de las Malvinas, el titular de la CNEA, vicealmirante Carlos Castro Madero, en forma reservada puso en marcha la idea de construir un submarino a propulsión nuclear como una forma de cerrar la brecha tecnológica con Gran Bretaña.

    Since Argentina in the 1980s was working on a Nuclear submarine project and the project was very advanced and in Argentina that they considered they had enough technology to build it however the price was USD$200 million dollars instead of the USD $120 million dollars the conventional submarine costed to Argentina, however the project was cancelled during the Mennen presidency

    http://www.defesanet.com.br/notas/argentina_nuclear_sub.htm

    in reply to: Argentina and Brazil to develop nuclear submarine #2090448
    MiG-23MLD
    Participant

    Will Chile join this common army? Will Peru, boivia and ecuador be ready to share an army? You still haven’t answered me as to who the common enemy or the threat is percieved to be?

    They are not mentioning any enemy or invader they are only saying under the regional plan an united South America will be modeled upon NATO and the EU, Argentina and Brazil have realized that the only way their nations can advance technologically and economically is to remain independent of any foreign power and the Brazilian economic planners know south america is rich in resources, it seems the most eager nations to join the south american army are Brazil, Argentina and Venezuela.

    Bolivia, Ecuador and Peru probably will join those plans in the same way Uruguay.

    Chile and Colombia are still two nations who still show not much interest or no interest at all, however as Mercosur grows the likelihood of that grows

    in reply to: Argentina and Brazil to develop nuclear submarine #2090514
    MiG-23MLD
    Participant

    So ? It will be 11 or more likely 12th country to join the list congrats. How long before it can launch its on weather, comm and recon sats? It will take 3 decades easily. The c-390 is seems like a useful option but who is providing the engines?

    The R-99 is eyerie (swedish) fitted on the embrarer damn it! AMX was built with italian help and can brazil or SA make a fighter on its own? Yes, I would guess in 3-4 decades. Leave the CH-14 out it is a very basic light attack heli with more use in COIN or anti Drug warfare that real wars. But its a start, kudos to argies. The CBERS seems more of chinese initiative but if brazil can built its own satellites at a later date, good for them but again will take atleast a couple of decades to build comm sats. When exactly was SA not independent? The Nuke sub unless its a boomer seems of little use in maintaining a deterrence but again to reach there easily 3 decades.

    Brazil already leads the SA space program. Whats your point? Are you saying they will share it with other SA countries?

    So you already have a member who will not join the SA union? YEs I can see that a FTA with local SA nations can be beneficial especially to Brazil and argentina but do you seriously see the block challenging US or EU economically in another 3-4 decades? I certainly don’t.

    Your stimates still reflect an ultra simplistic view of South america, number one under the current regional view a common army for all of south america is needed, this also means a commun defence industry where the common border is south america.

    see

    Un proyecto militar de esa magnitud sólo podía materializarse bajo condiciones como las actuales, con gobiernos como los de Cristina Fernández y Lula da Silva con la misma visión sobre la defensa regional, donde la frontera es Sudamérica. Como señaló Jobim, “el sentido de las Fuerzas Armadas sudamericanas es disuasorio y no expansionista. Pero ese poder de disuasión sólo se ejerce si hay por detrás una industria militar regional que nos independice de los suministros extranjeros”

    A military project of this size can only be realized only under the current conditions and Governments of Lula da Silva and Cristina Fernandez, that share the same view in matters of regional defence where the common border is the South american continent.

    The South american armed forces are not expansionist in nature but purely defensive, however to achieve that deterrance it is needed a common regional defence industry that free us from foreign arms suppliers

    source http://www.defesanet.com.br/al1/arg_k_l_2.htm

    In fact what is happening is very similar to the Panavia Tornado program but in this case of a nuclear submarine where Argentina and Brazil will develop a very small nuclear reactor based upon the argentine nuclear reactor CAREM in order to create a nuclear submarine..

    The whole point is Brazil by 2020 very likely will have nuclear submarines, cargo aircraft and satellite rocket launchers.

    O Ministro da Defesa , Nelson Jobim, explicou nesta segunda-feira (25/2) que o Brasil e a Argentina deverão criar uma empresa binacional para desenvolver reatores nucleares destinados exclusivamente à produção de energia elétrica. A iniciativa insere-se no acordo assinado entre os dois países na última sexta-feira (22/2) durante visita do presidente da República, Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva, ao país vizinho. O acordo visa à cooperação na área nuclear e energética, entre outros pontos.

    O Ministro da Defesa negou, no entanto, que a parceira Brasil-Argentina se estenda à construção do submarino nuclear brasileiro, diferentemente do que foi publicado no fim de semana em jornais argentinos. “É apenas para produção de energia”, esclareceu Jobim. O submarino nucelar, segundo o ministro, deverá ser produzido com tecnologia nuclear desenvolvida pelo Brasil, tendo à frente os centros de pesquisa da Marinha, em Iperó (SP).

    However the Brazilian defence minister said that Brazil will develop the nuclear reactor for the Brazilian nuclear submarine with Brazilian nuclear technology and the main treaty with Argentina was to create civil nuclear reactors to supply energy to cities

    http://www.defesanet.com.br/md1/sub_ar.htm

    in reply to: Argentina and Brazil to develop nuclear submarine #2090730
    MiG-23MLD
    Participant

    Ok you need to slow down. Whatever you said is not likely to occur in the next 3-4 decades.

    you need t do some reading, it will happen i can prove it to you.

    Brazil is at no more than 15 years to become an space fairing nation, with its own satellite launcher,
    http://www.spacetoday.org/images/Rockets/Brazil/BrazilVLSatAlcantara289x533.jpg
    they will have a locally made cargo aircraft the C390

    http://www.jblog.com.br/media/6/20070918-slot1109embraer.jpg
    , already Brazil has AWACs the R-99 ad light fighters the AMX, Argentina has built the CH-14 helicopter
    http://img208.imageshack.us/img208/2893/ch142wd1.jpg
    and has recovered the FMA from americans hands, they plan to have their own South american Banking system and create their own common currency, already Brazil has Satellites built with Chinese-Brazilian technology, Brazil very likely will stablish a United South america by 2030 and once the have full command of the nuclear sub technology and missile technology very likely the total independence of South american will be stablished.

    here are some Peruvian made sonda Rocket Very likely Brazil will lead a a south american space program

    http://sondaperu.com/cohete_orion.jpg

    http://www.aeb.gov.br/conteudo.php?ida=5&idc=145&id=810 here it is said Brazil and Argentina plan to build a satelllite togather Brazilian made VS-30 sonda rocket

    http://www.aeb.gov.br/vs30/fig/17.jpg

    http://news.bbc.co.uk/nolpda/ifs_news/hi/newsid_5195000/5195834.stm

    Mercosur is South America’s leading trading bloc. Known as the Common Market of the South, it aims to bring about the free movement of goods, capital, services and people among its member states.

    It has been likened to the European Union, but with an area of 12m sq km (4.6m sq miles), it is four times as big. The bloc’s combined market encompasses more than 250m people and accounts for more than three-quarters of the economic activity on the continent.

    Mercosur was set up in March 1991 by Argentina, Brazil, Paraguay and Uruguay under the Treaty of Asuncion. The 1994 Treaty of Ouro Preto gave the body a wider international status and formalised a customs union.

    Brazil and Argentina are Mercosur’s economic giants. Bolivia, Chile, Colombia, Ecuador and Peru are associate members; they can join free-trade agreements but remain outside the bloc’s customs union. Moves to include Chile as a full member were suspended after Santiago signed a free-trade deal with the US in 2002

    in reply to: Argentina and Brazil to develop nuclear submarine #2090778
    MiG-23MLD
    Participant

    I doubt they would be stupid enough to try Falkland-2. It will take atleast a decade to get the SSN in water and another decade tobe proficient in using it. Moreover a couple of astutes will deter them.

    i doubt they will attack again, i see no probability, however not because of the lack of weaponry in future years, in fact i think South america might become a military block and in future years might become a nuclear armed zone or at least a new military power, Brazil aims is to create a South american nation alongside Venezuela`s bolivarian revolution but with an economy as large as Germany or even Japan in the next 15 years.

    The first step theya re planing is keep South american for the South americans and that measn several nuclear submarines aircraft carriers and local made weapons already they have AWACS, light attack aircraft and soon to be joined by an Brazilian-Argentine made transport aircraft

    in reply to: Argentina and Brazil to develop nuclear submarine #2090892
    MiG-23MLD
    Participant

    I could see the 1st hull being launched in…saaay….30 years.

    I doubt it, i see a period of 15 years and 30 to make 2 or 3 nuclear subs, in
    a period of 30 years Brazil and Argentina will become one country and probably they will have nukes

Viewing 15 posts - 811 through 825 (of 2,930 total)