dark light

thobbes

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 15 posts - 901 through 915 (of 2,012 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: China fueling Naval Arms Race??? #1998879
    thobbes
    Participant

    I don’t think it’s fueling an arms race.

    If you look at it, Philippines modernisation is extremely limited and well overdue.

    Japanese modernisation is limited compared to 1980s – a mere 42 F-35 for total requirement (compared to 200+ F-15 and 130 F-2) and replacement of older equipment is nothing out of the ordinary.

    South Korea was on its own way to expansion in pursuit of a blue water capability whose purpose was not to counter China but rather show off Korea’s importance. North Koreans sabre rattling has put a stop to that and they’re refocusing on peninsula.

    Vietnam’s modernisation is limited too and very gradual.

    Compare all this to military build up in Middle East (Saudi Arabia, UAE and little Qatar) or even Russia’s rebuilding efforts.

    The Asians realise that they don’t need massive capability given Uncle Sam’s involvement in the region. Even Vietnam benefits for this and can as such gradually upgrade military.

    Remove Uncle Sam out of the equation and I suspect you’ll see military rearmament spike to levels not seen since Europe in 1950s.

    in reply to: Future RAF – Mixed Fighter Force re born #2274523
    thobbes
    Participant

    I think right now future of RAF is anyone’s guess – gotta wait for SDSR 2015.

    in reply to: Romania's fighter indecesion 2013!! #2274595
    thobbes
    Participant

    They’re meant to be getting 12 ex-Portuguese birds by 2017.

    in reply to: Future RAF – Mixed Fighter Force re born #2274600
    thobbes
    Participant

    I can’t see the British compromising on pilot training the way the French are intending to do.

    I suspect future RAF will be smaller – current strength is about 220 aircraft (120 Tornado, 100 Typhoon). Both Tornado and Tranche 1 Typhoons are to be retired by 2019, thus leaving 107 Typhoons.

    I don’t think RAF will order over 100 F-35s. (If Scotland leaves, number ordered will be even smaller). SDSR 2015 will reveal all in terms of current UK requirements.

    in reply to: Cold war prototypes that didn't make it #2275912
    thobbes
    Participant

    1957: The Aerfer Ariette was the first Italian supersonic jet aircraft – a prototype – it was a Sagittario derivative
    🙂

    With that long nose and squat landing gear, it looks a bit like Yak -23:

    http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/b/b4/Jak-23.JPG/300px-Jak-23.JPG

    thobbes
    Participant

    Seems the only aircraft flying regularly are the F-5s.

    in reply to: Taiwan retiring Mirage 2000 fleet?? #2275963
    thobbes
    Participant

    Yes, they are still running the old M60s. Although I personally find funding of tanks on a relatively small island as completely superfluous. Taiwan needs area denial weaponry in the first place, mostly subs. They only got two obsolete ones, AFAIK.

    Army likes toys too.

    in reply to: Vietnamese Air Force #2276210
    thobbes
    Participant

    Possibly XM177E2’s left over from war?

    But then could’ve been brought recently – spec ops types often have non-standard issue weapons and often of a higher quality than standard units.

    thobbes
    Participant

    And, IIRC, the F1s have rather been under the comand of the IRGC rather than IRAAF due to their “internal security”-role.

    Interesting as they have IRIAF stencilled on nose. Do IRGC aircraft carry IRIAF.

    Which makes sence since the lack of other armament than the gun (and perhaps unguided rockets or dumb bombs) make them of limite d military value for IRAAF

    That’s about the average capability for any IRIIAF ground attack tasked jet.

    And the fleet is just to small to make expensive upgrades worthwhile.

    I read a while back that both F-4D (some 10 airframes) and Mirage F1 (23 airframes in total, not all operational) were scheduled for retirement but all the US sabre rattling meant they decided to keep them.

    Most IRIAF aircraft types are operated in very small numbers – e.g. there’s only about 26 MiG-29s, 25 F-14s, 10 F-4Ds etc.

    In context of this, 23 Mirage F1 ariframes is reasonable.

    And especially so since the can not purchase first hand spareparts and sub systems on the open market due to international arms embargo on Iran.

    Apparently the Mirages, Sukhois and MiGs arrived with Il-76s full of spares.

    Also there is a lot of Mirage F1s floating around in countries with less than reputable reputations in terms of weapons dealing or adhering to US led sanctions – South Africa, Libya, Ecuador and now Gabon as transhipment point. I don’t see Morocco or Jordan smuggling weapons to Iran.

    It’d be easier to obtain F.1 parts than F-14 or even F-4D/E parts and Iran keeps both types in service.

    So, I’d guess the Iranis will just keep on flying their F1s in their current form untill the frames run out of flight hours, and then dispose of them.

    Apparently they’ve attained some sort of overhaul capability.

    The fact is as you say, these birds have been in service for more than a decade. Unless Iran is flying around in aircraft that anyone else would deem unsafe, it would appear they’ve reached some sort of self-sufficiency with them.

    I generally don’t believe any sort of BS coming out of Iran about new designs, but they have proved themselves resourceful in terms of keeping existing assets in the air without manufacturer support for decades, and during times of war.

    If they’re keeping their Mirage F1s, there might be an upgrade in the works ala F-4D/E plans (whatever happened to this by the way?).

    in reply to: Eurofighter vs Rafale for Qatar #2276282
    thobbes
    Participant

    Point is they’re not buying weapons from France or weapons that France has major contibution too.

    Most telling is replacement of AMX-30 with German Leopard 2 instead of Leclerc (which is used by UAE).

    But then if I had money, I’d be buying latest spec Leo 2’s as well.

    in reply to: Taiwan retiring Mirage 2000 fleet?? #2276605
    thobbes
    Participant

    The Mirages and Lafayettes were sold in the 1990s. China was a lot less powerful then.

    Most European countries have been restricting sales to Taiwan since 1990s.

    Chinese-French relationship has been heavily strengthened since then:

    http://www.diplomatie.gouv.fr/en/country-files/china-506/france-and-china/economic-relations-5696/

    http://english.people.com.cn/90883/8223292.html

    The French would gladily turn down a small sale of some military equipment to Taiwan than threaten tens of billions of dollars worth of investments and exports to China as well as access to one of the biggest markets.

    Also French see China as a useful asset in terms of promoting a multi-polar world i.e. one not just dominated by US. In multi-polar world, a medium power like France has far more input than one dominated by a single super power.

    in reply to: Taiwan retiring Mirage 2000 fleet?? #2276613
    thobbes
    Participant

    I heard a few years back that they were considering retiring Mirages due to engine problems, high wear and tear and extreme cost. Engine problems were apparently resolved. However no retirement date was set for Mirage 2000.

    I think F-5 retirement date is 2017 but could be wrong.

    According to below article Taiwan AF will be experiencing aircraft shortage by 2020 though M2000 is not mentioned:

    http://www.taipeitimes.com/News/front/archives/2012/05/26/2003533746/1

    Has anyone heard anything additional?

    Oh and thanks to an accident this year, fleet is now 55 aircraft.

    in reply to: Eurofighter vs Rafale for Qatar #2276630
    thobbes
    Participant

    What is clear is that you have no idea about the relation between these two governements. For instance, I don’t think that investors from Qatar has any tax exemptions in US like what exist in France.

    We’re talking military alliances. US is number 1 player here (with 2 US bases located on Qatari territory).

    It;s like Australia is completely in league with America militarily (51st state goshdarnit), but economically we’re far more closer to Asia and in particular China, South Korea and Japan.

    Yeah, he clearly didn’t notice their army and air force was mainly using French operational organization, using mainly French equipment across the board, dependent on French weapons for the majority of their needs. The UK is probably closer to fourth place behind the US and Germany when it comes to military acquisitions. Even that place is threatened by the sales from the Netherlands and Italy.

    French equipment – yes. Mostly brought in the 1980s (Alpha Jet, Gazelle, AMX30ss, Mirage F1) and 1990s (Mirage 2000).

    It’s like saying Poland is aligned with Russia because most of it’s equipment is still of Soviet origin.

    Latest purchases for Qatar have been a variety of countries German Leopard 2, Pzh2000 SPG, Swiss Mowag Piranhas and PC-21s, Italian AW139s, US C-17s, C-130s (and requested THAAD, MH-60 and AH-64),

    I’m not seeing orders of Leclercs, Cougars, NH90s, Tigres, A400s etc here, which would signify linking in with France more closely. In fact a while back they were considering replacing M2000-5 with F-16 so they’re more compatible with US.

    As for organisation, have you any proof it’s organised along French lines? I thought it was organised along British lines? A lot of the army is Pakistanis (native Qataris are only about 30% of armed forces) so that would also seem to indicate a British model.

    Finally anyone have any idea as to current order of battle?

    What squadrons were formed or converted to AW139 and C-130J?

    EDIT: Scramble states 20 Sqn has been created for AW139s. C-130 squadron number is not known:

    http://www.scramblemagazine.nl/orbats/qatar/airforce

    in reply to: Zumwalt taking shape……….. #1999366
    thobbes
    Participant

    So looking forward to seeing how ugly this thing’s going to be in real life.

    Shame it doesn’t have some 12-16 inch guns though.

    in reply to: Eurofighter vs Rafale for Qatar #2276929
    thobbes
    Participant

    They’re talking 24-36 aircraft.

    As for alliance, they aren’t that close to France.

    They’re closer to the USA, with whom they share bases (Al Udeid Air Base or As Saliyah Army Base where US has prepositioned equipment).

Viewing 15 posts - 901 through 915 (of 2,012 total)