dark light

TomcatViP

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 15 posts - 3,211 through 3,225 (of 5,621 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: SAAB Gripen and Gripen NG thread #4 #2195049
    TomcatViP
    Participant

    Are you sure? I think I have read in the F-35 thread that the experts over there believe F-35 to become as affordable as Gripen. I may be wrong of course.

    Spud and FBW where are you?

    It’s even more substantiated than that. Pardon me for repeating myself but Switzerland with it’s topographic particularities and population centers can benefits of reduced expenses and nuisances (what will appeal directly to voters) with a vstol stealth aircraft. The OP increases and the strongest deterrence will also lower in overall the cost associated with a credible defense. This is of utmost importance in the foreseeable future with what looks like a more difficult defense scenario and to help fulfill the needs of others forces (army) with the expected increase in their budgets (draft means voters that pay more attention to the material being at their disposal).

    Operating from plateaus instead of populated valley will alleviate many of the difficulties encountered today and reinforce the defense posture.

    in reply to: UCAV/UAV/UAS News and discussion 2015 #2195795
    TomcatViP
    Participant

    yeah, looks like a dumb execution of a good concept
    probably expensive too
    and those rotors aren’t a very efficient way of flying

    what you want is something like this
    http://www.nationaldefensemagazine.org/archive/2012/October/PublishingImages/DTN_robotics.jpg

    hang a grenade on it and fly it towards the enemy
    it’s faster, cheaper and has better endurance

    also you’d want a UAV that can drop the grenade, so you can reuse the UAV
    a small UAV flying at any decent altitude and speed would be quick enough to avoid enemy fire

    You said it all ?

    in reply to: UCAV/UAV/UAS News and discussion 2015 #2195875
    TomcatViP
    Participant

    9lb guys!
    Who is going to carry one time use of this weight into battle? What do you swap for that? A radio, a med Pac or your riffle?
    An idiot got some string to pull and the media jump on it*. What a news!

    * without even mentioning the reported 200m range where that things is undetectable…

    in reply to: Air operations against Daesh/IS news and debate. #2196239
    TomcatViP
    Participant

    Divide it for the number of the F/A-18 involved i.e. SIX, please. Result is less than one in three days each.

    Repeat: sortie means every time a single plane take off for a mission.

    Yes, you are perfectly right but we need to understand that they brought in 6 planes for the largest effort (a strike etc…). Most of the mission involves armed persistence above the Theatre of Op. Hence not all mission involves a maximum number of sorties (see the number of daily strikes irrelevant with the number of assets).

    How I read those number is that 2 planes are launched Every Day in support of the coalition. The rest is not used or on maintenance. Given the 1.95, it means that those two planes are available everyday on average, what constitute a good performance given that it is a deployment half the globe around.

    A comparison with other air forces will surely underline this (and let’s be clear, if the Au Mod had to shy from those numbers there won’t probably have not been such clear publication, perhaps).

    in reply to: Eurofighter Typhoon discussion and news 2015 #2196243
    TomcatViP
    Participant

    You don’t need terrain masking 100miles out of the most potent threat. A penetration down the deck would be made only to face the most capable radar. This is all about a stealth fighter. Hence, lo lo lo, does not apply much if we are to deal with the higher value of combat range.

    in reply to: Indian Air Force Thread 20 #2196268
    TomcatViP
    Participant

    The first thing, I would say, is that it has to be really cheap. AERO Vodochi failed that market despite a lower manpower cost. On the other side of the equation, there is also some cheap fighters easily (?) available like the Jf 17 and the Teja. So acquisition cost is the key as modern design like the Scorpion have already set the bar high (low in fact) in term of operating costs.

    Would it make sense to operate such attack Hawk derivative b/w a fleet of Tejas?

    in reply to: Military Aviation News #2196275
    TomcatViP
    Participant

    China tracked U.S. F-22 Raptors over East China Sea, analyst says

    China’s People’s Liberation Army said it had identified F-22s of unknown origin flying over the East China Sea, and in response deployed helicopters and a naval vessel, Taiwan’s Central News Agency reported Monday.

    I fail to understand how a single user aircraft can be of “unknown origin” and what links their detection with the deployment of “helicopters and a naval vessel”

    Is there around some Raptors fitted with floats and operated by pirates?

    in reply to: Indian Air Force Thread 20 #2196335
    TomcatViP
    Participant

    Yes you are right. It was more pretext for some nice pics and nose arts. But the above detailed pack looks impressive enough if the engine can back all the added weight.

    Interestingly, the reduced weight and increased lethality of modern weapons have made this kind of refit a credible niche. When the hawk200 was rolled out, those were factor detrimental to its success.

    in reply to: Eurofighter Typhoon discussion and news 2015 #2196337
    TomcatViP
    Participant

    Why would you fly a lo lo lo mission in a stealth aircraft?
    A penetration down the deck, perhaps but not the full flight.

    in reply to: Indian Air Force Thread 20 #2196346
    TomcatViP
    Participant

    With no backseat pilot, install an ammo drum and a 25mm Gatling gun in the nose. Call it the Hoghawk.
    Damn, wish one of our artist here would make a frankenplane pic out of it!

    in reply to: Air operations against Daesh/IS news and debate. #2196794
    TomcatViP
    Participant

    I guess now we can expect economic sanctions on Suadi Arabia.. Oh, wait…
    .

    This news article was published in May 2015… I guess that it have to be read with a pinch of salt’s giving the drastic contextual change that have happened since.

    in reply to: RuAF News and development Thread part 15 #2197106
    TomcatViP
    Participant

    It’s the first time I see Raf for Rafale…

    1Saludo

    It’s a very personal abbreviation, obviously. You are then totally excused if you’d accept my apologies for having induced you in error 😉

    in reply to: Air operations against Daesh/IS news and debate. #2197134
    TomcatViP
    Participant

    FA18F:
    7 months of OP at 30.5 days per months
    418 sorties
    => 1.95 sorties per days.
    If we include the month of February as it is with a lower total number of days, this will raise slightly.

    It is astonishing for the number of planes involved and the distance from the Theater of Operation (11500km). You are not going to do that with a bunch of Kfir!

    Also with the kind of fight involved, the number of sorties does not have to be correlated with the number of ammunition delivered. Most of the flight doesn’t see a live fire.

    in reply to: Military Aviation News #2197136
    TomcatViP
    Participant

    Lebanon Army Commander Jean Kahwaji as saying:Lebanon’s armed forces would receive six A-29 Super Tucano light attack aircraft “soon”.

    Saudi Arabia cancels $4bn aid package for Lebanon’s security forces

    Surprisingly, there are still no reactions from the Fr gov. Interestingly also, this cancellation happens before any of the bulk of shipping had been made (essentially Milan’ missiles so far) and at a moment when SA forces start been engaged in the theater of operation.

    DÚs le début du contrat, « la crainte de voir ses armements tomber aux mains » du mouvement armé chiite libanais avait été prise trÚs au sérieux confiait un industriel concerné.

    Mais l’Arabie saoudite souhaite aussi revoir sa politique d’achat d’armement avec la France en se dĂ©barrassant de certains intermĂ©diaires.

    Translation (Google_Mod):
    From the beginning of the contract, “the fear of those arms falling into the hands” of the Lebanese Shiite armed movement had been taken very seriously said an industrial concerned by the deal.

    But Saudi Arabia also wants to review its arms procurement policy with France and get rid of some of its intermediates.

    Edit:
    It is rumored today in DefenseNews.com that the six A29 deal (US) is not affected. Other weapon package delivery from US as well.

    Source:
    Rfi.fr
    Defensenews.com

    in reply to: Air operations against Daesh/IS news and debate. #2197192
    TomcatViP
    Participant

    The fact that this has not been posted already in the Indian Air Force thread shows that we lack here a Boeing paid troll to re-use a popular name-calling. Sorties number are astonishing.

Viewing 15 posts - 3,211 through 3,225 (of 5,621 total)