dark light

Otaku

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 15 posts - 811 through 825 (of 1,246 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: Su-34 vs F-15E – design and performance #2473176
    Otaku
    Participant

    Relevance?

    Well when the Russkies inherit the ISS in a couple of years time, they’ll be able to clamp on an enormous conformal solar-powered COTS GaN AESA which will track Russian titanium in the F-22 & 35.

    Or maybe PM Putin can’t wait ’till then and will sign a decree scaling-back VSMPO Avisma exports, hence screwing the F-35 too.

    The pen is truly mightier than the AESA (all 5 models of them).

    in reply to: Flankers beats F-35 in highly classified simulated dogfight ? #2473805
    Otaku
    Participant

    I really donโ€™t think very much of people that write articles like this or the people that post them.

    Here’s 2 more:

    http://blog.wired.com/defense/2008/09/us-stealth-figh.html
    http://www.f-16.net/f-16_forum_viewtopic-t-11048.html

    “…if the USAF doesn’t want to bet it’s future on JSF, why should you?”
    -definite ‘Uncle Sam’ poster banner material.

    in reply to: BLACKJACKs In Venezuela #2474196
    Otaku
    Participant

    Tu-160s in Venezuela and Venezuela to become first export customer (if not launch) for Su-35?:

    http://www.flightglobal.com/articles/2008/09/15/315926/tupolev-tu-160-pair-make-first-transatlantic-flight.html

    in reply to: SU-35 , how will it sell? #2474198
    Otaku
    Participant

    From an economic point of view – its just part of the DoD budget – like all the systems – eventually the US government re-capitilis(z)es that cash spent through tax anyway – while stimulating one of the Wests biggest industries.

    Anecdote to Keynsian Macro-economics 101:

    US Budget Deficit 2008 (baseline): $407bn
    US Budget Deficit 2009 (post Fannie & Freddie): $530bn, to remain 3-4% of GDP for the next decade totalling $7,000bn in extra debt (most optimistic projection)

    US FY2008 Defense Budget: $481.4bn

    Putting things in perspective:Lehman Brothers’ outstanding debt total: $600bn (that’s 2 x JSF programme)

    sources: CBO & FT.

    in reply to: Flankers beats F-35 in highly classified simulated dogfight ? #2474485
    Otaku
    Participant

    I think people should be reminded more often of what stealth realy is.

    Sukhoi is doing intensive research on low-observability design…reducing the radar cross-section through airframe shaping and surface design, [the use of] absorbent coatings and lowering [electronic & infra-red] emissions…Our top priorities are high performance small-signature aircraft, integrated airframe and engine designs, laminar flow techniques, lower heat transfer and hypersonic technology…”

    Mikhail Pogosyan, General-Director of Sukhoi Aviation Holding Company @ Sir Thomas Sopwith Lecture, RAeS, London, 10th July 2008.

    in reply to: Flankers beats F-35 in highly classified simulated dogfight ? #2474871
    Otaku
    Participant

    Personally, I consider much a waste of time to even rebut.

    Hey, I’m just floating an idea (albeit a bit extreme/worst of the worst case scenarios). I mean stranger things have happened- who’d have thought 18months ago US sub-prime mortgage fallout would lead to near global financial meltdown?

    Let’s look at a better case scenario, as per bring_it_on above: cuts in numbers acquired which will bloat unit costs to well over $100m (today’s prices, note probable sustained $ recovery)-either way potential customers will look to more cost effective alternatives- maybe Boeing still considers the SH as offering considerable growth potential, Eurocanards & Su-35 may join the fray- dare I say it maybe even PAK-FA-MK(X)?!

    in reply to: Super-Hornet in the IAF as MRCA #2474877
    Otaku
    Participant

    Maybe it was a bristol university computer simulation of a simulation ๐Ÿ˜‰

    in reply to: Flankers beats F-35 in highly classified simulated dogfight ? #2475010
    Otaku
    Participant

    Wont happen in my opinion , the F-35 would most likely be scaled back , dates pushed forward , purchases reduced to a point where it becomes really really expensive and we still buy a less competant system then what the service wanted at greater the cost. Why change such a genious procurment process ๐Ÿ™‚ .

    This is a horrendous situation. Imho, the US DoD should cancel all domestic orders for F-35, depending on contractual default penalty costs, honouring export orders only (taking a leaf out-of Sukhoi’s book).

    Secondly, re-open F-22 production line with LRP orders and open a tender for a 6G fighter post 2020- meantime adopt SH as a stop-gap, unless the US Govt. has plans to ask the Russians & Chinese to lend them the money for F-35 procurement (irony of ironies).

    in reply to: Flankers beats F-35 in highly classified simulated dogfight ? #2475032
    Otaku
    Participant

    Well qn is whether they even have any firm plan to develop the same, or its just another marketing gimmick. A look at the JSF and F-22 programs shows how expensive and time consuming such endeavours to make the “next generation” warplane, can be.

    Boeing’s 6G will probably be along the lines of a manned UCAV (as per USAF’s Next-Gen. Bomber scaled-up), possibly a derivative of ‘Bird of Prey’ but with non-metalic structural spars and next-gen coatings- implying extensive use of nano-tech, use of a modified existing engine to keep costs down.

    Maybe Boeing’s marketing pitch to the DoD is along the lines of: ‘buy more SH’s blk3 now, reduce JSF orders- and we’ll deliver you a 6th Gen fighter mid-2020s’-on time & on budget.

    Regardless, Boeing certainly scents blood as JSF hits the buffers. I wonder if cancellation is a remote or even a distinct possibility- especially considering the gloom in the US economy & dire Govt. finances.

    [ATTACH]165269[/ATTACH]

    in reply to: Su-34 vs F-15E – design and performance #2475442
    Otaku
    Participant

    M. Pogosyan reported that the Su-34 will receive uprated engines and an active array in the future.

    However, imho, I think Su-34 will remain in LRIP @ NAPO, with the RuAF adopting the 2-seater Indo-Russian PAK-FA in the dedicated strike role, hence few Su-34s will be procured only to help plug the gap ’till around 2020- much the same intention as its stablemate the Su-35…kinda makes sense really.

    in reply to: Su-34 vs F-15E – design and performance #2475677
    Otaku
    Participant

    Recent Su-34 video, note production representative cockpit (5 AMLCDs) [02:12], GPS/GLONASS bomb test-drop [06:08] ๐Ÿ˜Ž

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oBH5AjY-BLM

    in reply to: JSF: The Latest Hotspot in the U.S. Defense Meltdown #2476326
    Otaku
    Participant

    New Aussie fighter ‘clubbed like seal’
    somehow i feel we’re not being told the whole story

    “People with greater insight [into the F-35 programme] than I are looking at the [other] offerings available…Let people draw their own conclusions about why…”
    Tom Bell, Boeing.

    You’re damn right we’re not being told the whole story.

    in reply to: JSF: The Latest Hotspot in the U.S. Defense Meltdown #2476659
    Otaku
    Participant

    Are those TWr figures for real? ๐Ÿ˜ฎ

    I wonder if the ‘Lead Sled II’ will get ‘Fannie & Freddie’d’.๐Ÿ˜€

    in reply to: SU-35 , how will it sell? #2477047
    Otaku
    Participant

    You can think what you want but the Su-35 is obsolete compared to an F-22

    Nobody disputes that claim- least of all Sukhoi, RuAF/MoD. The question is, will the Su-35/27SM2 (production example) be second only to the Raptor(and later PAK-FA), irrespective of delivery time-lines & in-service dates- to which, imho, I’d say yes.

    Hence, so-long as it remains price-competitive with it’s generational contemporaries it’s a definite front-runner, especially where 5th Gen are prohibitively expensive.
    Remember, its new AA weapons have yet to be publicly unveiled and NIIP rates the Irbis’ capabilities so highly that it rules out an AESA upgrade.

    Ironically, it’s the run-away success of the Su-30 series and their MLUs (BARS AESA+weapons) that would seriously hamper exports, but that’s an internal KnAAPO/Irkut/NAPO battle.

    in reply to: SU-35 , how will it sell? #2477318
    Otaku
    Participant

    So France could stand to lose two potential customers in Libya and Brazil if they choose the Su-35..that would be one heck of a loss for them in that case.

    what about Iran?

    Agreed, I think the Libyan order is imminent (at least 12 aircraft), Yak-130 trainers have already been ordered (6) -tied in to Soviet era debt write-off.

    Brazil, as per FX-2 (36), is likely to select Su-35 due to high ToT, and a long-term future upgrade/supplement with PAK-FA (iirc to be negotiated next spring).

    Nevertheless, Su-35 vs. Superhornet & Eurocanards…should be interesting!! ๐Ÿ˜Ž

Viewing 15 posts - 811 through 825 (of 1,246 total)