dark light

Otaku

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 15 posts - 826 through 840 (of 1,246 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: SU-35 , how will it sell? #2477508
    Otaku
    Participant

    Not to detract from the formidable capabilities of the Su-35BM, but I get the sneaky suspicion that the RuAF is a reluctant (if necessary) launch customer:

    http://www.nxtbook.com/nxtbooks/aw/dti0908/index.php?startid=28

    in reply to: Super-Hornet in the IAF as MRCA #2478059
    Otaku
    Participant

    Indeed! Terrible waste of bandwidth and …what an utter bore.

    Agreed, now let’s debate AN/APG-79’s bandwidth…infact, let’s devote a thread to it! 😎

    in reply to: Effect of the MRCA contract on the Winner #2479592
    Otaku
    Participant

    Imho, Boeing’s SH is the clear favourite, especially after clearing the landmark nuke deal with the US. Boeing can offer the best industrial offsets, maybe they’ll do a fruity tie-in with P-8s -and it’s easily the finest in the tender.

    SH’s AN/APG-79 is leagues ahead of Zhuk-AE, but the most advanced MMICs will shortly be available as COTS (e.g Toshiba GaN HEMT), so why would the Russians (or anyone else, for that matter) want to re-invent the wheel?

    I wonder if India will purchase Growlers too 😎

    Otaku
    Participant

    RSM55, I won’t link part 2 of ‘RuAF in Georgia’ for fear of being ‘Smerched’ -speaking of which, these should make you happy:

    http://missiles.ru/foto_IDELF-2008.htm

    in reply to: Effect of the MRCA contract on the Winner #2480793
    Otaku
    Participant
    in reply to: The Military Situation in Georgia, S.O. and Abkhazia Part II #2481602
    Otaku
    Participant
    in reply to: IAF – News & Discussion #2481907
    Otaku
    Participant

    Yeah well India has been lagging in fighter radars, there simply isnt enough manpower and funding allocated for these projects.

    Why re-invent the wheel? Just think of those juicy offsets & voluptuous ToT agreements for MMRCA!!

    Plus, if the West puts technological/dual-use sanctions on Russia over Georgia- India will be elevated to uber-best buddy status. Watch for more high-tech JVs as a matter of necessity, with no bickering over ToT & costing.

    No-matter how PAK-FA AESA progresses, I’ll bet they’re aching to get a close look at AN/APG-79/ CaptorM etc.

    in reply to: IAF – News & Discussion #2481916
    Otaku
    Participant

    I look forward to India’s kick-ass 2 seater multi-role PAK-FA-MKI stealth fighter, with its kick-ass indigenous AESA (using COTS Toshiba GaN HEMT technology :cool:) it’ll make the Russkies jealous 😉

    in reply to: IAF – News & Discussion #2482245
    Otaku
    Participant

    :rolleyes::D:rolleyes::D:rolleyes::D
    Gee, what reply were you expecting Otaku? 😀

    Change is good:), but change is hard:(

    http://www.domain-b.com/aero/mil_avi/mil_aircraft/20080808_sukhoi.html

    in reply to: IAF – News & Discussion #2482612
    Otaku
    Participant
    in reply to: Russian/Georgian conflict impact of India? #2485453
    Otaku
    Participant

    “Consensus expert opinion”? …then I’m very glad I’m unlikely ever to have any business dealings with you.

    Hmmm…..applying the ‘swerve paradox/180 filter’ to your post means you do want dealings……but alas, I won’t be sharing my secrets of futures trading with you.

    in reply to: Russian/Georgian conflict impact of India? #2485487
    Otaku
    Participant

    Neo-con? Me? Have you never read any of my posts?

    The most important post of yours that I read was your ferocious defence of the British Army’s treatment of the resident Gurkhas- when I implied it was less than gracious……two days later there was a massive rally in central London by Gurkha vets (some very recently retired/discharged) demanding better pay, pensions, citizenship rights etc.etc. -So you don’t know the reality of your own back yard, but you take the authoratative tone on the politics of the N.Caucasus.

    Let me fill in your flawed knowledge. The concensus expert opinion is that this is a geo-political master-stroke by Putin et.al. That’s why everyone is stumped as to how to respond. Emotionally charged & impetuous out-bursts by Sakaashvilli merely highlight the fact (much to the embarrassment of Condi the other day).

    Testosterone has very little to do with it- that’s just the story spun to the dumb-dumb in the street.

    in reply to: Russian/Georgian conflict impact of India? #2485506
    Otaku
    Participant

    Also, whatever his faults (& there’s no doubt he has many), Saakashvili was democratically elected, & poses no threat to the security or territorial integrity of Russia. His attempts to regain control of territories his predecessors (particularly the rather nasty Gamsakhurdia) lost are no threat to Russia. If Russias leadership had more sense than testosterone, instead of the other way round, they’d have offered Georgia help in re-integrating the secessionist areas in exchange for Georgian co-operation in other areas, & achieved real security on their Caucasian border far more cheaply & easily than by fighting.

    Wowsers!! Nicely selective interpretation of history & geopolitics- like it came straight out of ‘The End of History’.
    Fyi most people (including the author Fukuyama) don’t believe that simplistic crap anymore, so you can put down your neo-con drum and ponder the one word retort…….Iraq.🙂

    in reply to: IAF – News & Discussion #2485706
    Otaku
    Participant

    Hi Abhimanyu, the recent (credible) press reports/official soundings out of India state PAK-FA-MKI will be a 2 seater- hence we can assume considerable Indian design & engineering input (as opposed to what we previously alluded to & explains the considerable time-gap to the single-seater’s first flight 2009 & 12 respectively).

    A 2 seater may also find its way into RuAF service, particularly in the strike role, perhaps explaining why so few Su-34s are being procured.

    Your thoughts?

    in reply to: Russian/Georgian conflict impact of India? #2485854
    Otaku
    Participant

    Personally, I wouldn’t be surprised to see India to begin to distances itself more and more from Russia as time goes on. Especially, if Russia continues its evil ways toward Eastern European Countries and former Soviet Republics like Georgia.

    Scooter, to put it in it’s simplest terms: Georgia is to Russia what Mexico is to the US, now could you imagine the US tollerating a Chavez type in power in Mexico? (in fact, you could argue they won’t even tollerate Chavez in Venezuela for much longer).

    As for India, if even the Israelis heed Russian requests over UAV supplies, the Germans & French shy away from stern measures, really puts things in perspective- the effect on longstanding Russian-Indian bonds trade/energy, political/strategic will be zero.

Viewing 15 posts - 826 through 840 (of 1,246 total)