At the end of the day, nothing changes the fact that no pilot, of any nation, in any aircraft type has ever beaten the F-15 in combat A2A, period, dot.
The fictitious “victory” over USAF Eagles at Cope India has been exposed ad nauseum on this forum, as has the formation-flying “dogfight” at Langley, I believe. And I don’t think even the most hard-core America bashers will believe Venik’s claims over Serbia.
I’m not claiming the Eagle is invincible, but I do think that until someone manages to bring one down in another machine, or at least verifiably and consistently defeats it in a realistic A2A exercise (i.e., the Eagle gets to use its full capabilities), it remains the top dog.