dark light

Rimmer

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 15 posts - 196 through 210 (of 542 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: Indian Air Force in Red Flag #2424592
    Rimmer
    Participant

    Hi Rimmer … its not the word of one Air Force against another. None of the points I have written in this post which has now been circulated EVERYWHERE have been questioned either by the US or Indian Air Force.

    The US Colonel in question was never a legitimate USAF voice on the exercises themselves. As mentioned, he was not directly linked with the day to day operations of Red Flag and many of his points were inaccurate. There has, since, been a letter of clarification from the USAF to the IAF explaining how the Colonel was expressing his own views, not those of anyone representing Red Flag.

    Thanks
    Vishnu

    OK, let me put it this way, If the USAF whupped IAF asses, they would never put it on record. Thats called diplomacy. The USAF Col was speaking off the record and you contridicted this yes in your next post you say

    ” the radar was used in training mode, a mode which IAF pilots told me was “very robust.”

    So you dont want to believe USAF guys off the record but happy to qoute IAF pilots off the record.

    Do you see what I mean now when I say it is one air forces word against another?

    in reply to: Indian Air Force in Red Flag #2424703
    Rimmer
    Participant

    Has this not been argued over many times before?

    Its essentially one air forces word against another.

    in reply to: Pakistan Air Force II #2424750
    Rimmer
    Participant

    Teer

    I posted a newsreports hsowing this was a request made in December and some of the bombs are a version we have not asked for. Its obvious to anyone what that means. When Pakistan receives EDAs it actually does not have to be notified when there is no contract and they are completely free.Like in the case of the 14 surplus F-16s we got.

    As I said, belive what you like, you will soon see contract awards for more bombs.

    Mirage and F-16s are Atlis capable. There was news reports we received targeting pods from US 3-4 months ago. The details of these are classified.

    PAF’s exact PGM strength will always be classified, but it is a mix of US, French and now with JF-17 , Chinese systems. For it’s size PAF would have a large holding.

    The most important thing is that alot of PAF pilots are flying combat missions and using PGMs in combat. This experiance coupled with the host of international exercises we are doing and High Mark 2010 and flying with AWACs means we are developing a large cadre of experianced and well trained pilots.

    in reply to: Pakistan Air Force II #2424853
    Rimmer
    Participant

    Well, given the PAF states that it needs PGMs for its ongoing ops, they may have asked the US to expedite delivery, so these were pulled from USAF stocks. IIRC a similar approach was taken when the Israelis asked for PGMs asap to top up their depleted stocks.

    Also, the numbers could be different, because these are part of the batch and not the entire lot. The PAF overall GBU 12/et al LGB orders stand at some 1600, so this could be part of the batch.

    Now, about the compatability issue, I think even that can be addressed. IIRC to properly explot the capabilities of an AMRAAM C7, one really does need the APG-68V(9) but a LGB can be dropped by just about any Viper, provided the proper s/w update is done to the stores management and weapons control system.

    I have been doing a bit of digging but still cant find any link that testifies this is a separate order from the original, hence my query If you do come across something, please share it.

    Sigh, it may be the batch, it may not. Does not matter, PAF has more then enough PGMs. The fact we got 1,000 in on delivery means these were probably US stocks, we will only pay for brand new bombs. Guess we may never know, but being a Major Non NATO Ally and acess to EDA means it is not even an issue…….

    However, you may be able to work out that these are a new batch from this report. Not the previous order was placed couple of years ago this new batch was requested in December. Also not orginal order did not include GBU-10s while the recent deliveries from US stocks do include them.

    I must admit,I do enjoy it when I am right!

    US to send Pakistan laser-guided bomb kits
    Tue Mar 2, 2010 3:29pm ESTRelated NewsHolbrooke hails Pakistan-U.S. collaboration on Taliban
    Thu, Feb 18 2010
    UPDATE 2-U.S. Air Force sees tanker terms by end Feb.
    Thu, Feb 18 2010
    Pakistan shows action, eyes talks, with Taliban arrest
    Thu, Feb 18 2010Stocks
    Lockheed Martin Corporation
    LMT.N
    $84.12
    +1.03+1.24%
    7:00pm UTC
    Raytheon Company
    RTN.N
    $56.56
    -0.12-0.21%
    7:00pm UTC
    WASHINGTON, March 2 (Reuters) – The United States will deliver 1,000 laser-guided bomb kits to Pakistan this month and is considering additional arms sales to help the Pakistani air force crack down on insurgents in the Afghan border region.

    Stocks | Industrials

    Air Force Secretary Michael Donley told reporters on Tuesday the arms sales came in response to a request made by the air chief of the Pakistani air force in December.

    “There continues to be a dialogue back and forth,” Donley said, noting that the U.S. government had already agreed to sell Pakistan munitions and night vision goggles, and was also stepping up training.

    Pakistan is also expected to receive new F-16 fighters made by Lockheed Martin Corp (LMT.N) this spring or summer, Donley said, noting that the fighter jets would give Pakistan’s air force greatly expanded capabilities in its fight against “radical elements” in the border region.

    Lockheed spokeswoman Laurie Quincy said the first of the 18 F-16s ordered by Pakistan was accepted by the Pakistani government in December but was still completing preparations to be ferried to the country later this year.

    Air Force spokesman Lieutenant Colonel Jeffry Glenn said the United States delivered 1,000 MK-82 500-pound bombs to Pakistan last month, and was considering additional requests for those bombs and more laser-guided tail kits.

    Glenn said an initial batch of 700 GBU-12 and 300 GBU-10 Paveway laser-guided bomb kits built by Lockheed and Raytheon Co (RTN.N) would be delivered to Pakistan this month, allowing the Pakistani air force to outfit the MK-82 bombs delivered last month with sophisticated technology that allows better targeting of the weapons.

    The expected delivery later this year of 18 F-16s to Pakistan will bring its inventory of the planes to 54. Pakistan has been operating F-16s since 1982.

    Donley said Pakistan was also upgrading the capabilities of its older F-16 fighter jets. (Reporting by Andrea Shalal-Esa; Editing by Cynthia Osterman)

    http://www.reuters.com/article/idUSN0217277420100302?type=marketsNews

    in reply to: Pakistan Air Force II #2424876
    Rimmer
    Participant

    High Mark 2010

    in reply to: Pakistan Air Force II #2424888
    Rimmer
    Participant

    PAF COAS launching High Mark 2010 (That or checking his Facebook status!) 😉

    in reply to: Military Aviation News from around the world – V #2424914
    Rimmer
    Participant

    Next would be re-admission into Russian federation, which may well be a good thing for Georgia, Russia and regional stability, Ukraine to follow.

    The most politically bias, unrelated and dubioous post ever on an Aviation news thread. Well done!

    in reply to: Pakistan Air Force II #2424980
    Rimmer
    Participant

    I would think JF-17 is certainly top aicraft before MLU/Block 52s arrive.

    It certainly outlcasses our F-16A/Bs in avionics.

    PAF will always rate the A/B as its major frontline platform as it has over 25 years experiance on this platform and as we have seen alot of equipment and spare parts are free.

    in reply to: Pakistan Air Force II #2425265
    Rimmer
    Participant

    Is there any source/link which points out this is a separate package and not that contracted earlier. Because it seems to be part of the same package (GBU-12 etc).

    Reports say these were “rushed to Pakistan” from US stocks, also you will note the numbers from bother batches are different. The other batch is also part of Block 52 order, whilst the batch we have received will be used by all PAF aircraft that can use it in service now.

    in reply to: UK Defence Review Part I #2425590
    Rimmer
    Participant

    Brigades like 16 AA and 3 CMDO are very composite. Rarely do all three CMDOs or all three PARA units go into battle with it.It is almost always just 2 battalions or 2 plus a regular inf battalion acting in the Airborne or Marine role.

    Often a PARA or CMDO regiment will be in training or on other duties.

    For this reason Britain will need more then just 2-3 Armoured units in order to throw in a dedicated Armored Brigade as in 2003.

    some units will be in rest periods other will be in training. What Britain did in 2003 was actually steal tanks and parts from units not participating in GW2.

    If they cut down any further they will have no units to “steal” from or borrow manpower from.

    Cutting down a tank force to anything below 250 odd units and you will look less and less lilely to be able to send an armoured brigade away.

    This logic is less likely to apply to light specialised units like the PARAs and Marines as no such equipment is required bar C-130s/Chinooks for the PARAS.

    in reply to: Military Aviation News from around the world – V #2425611
    Rimmer
    Participant

    The Aviación Militar Venezolana took delivery of its first of 6 K-8W

    http://favclub.powweb.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2010/03/k8wFC8.jpg

    http://favclub.powweb.com/blog/

    Here is the link with news and other pictures.

    Saludos.

    That is the best ever K-8 colour scheme I haveever seen. K-8 looks a bit tough in it! Nice!

    in reply to: Military Aviation News from around the world – V #2425613
    Rimmer
    Participant

    They have replied to the RFI and did a demo on F 35 capabilities to the IN.

    Yes India is unlikely to get early slots, but IAC 2 is some way away by the time I think F 35 would be ready.

    F-35 was NEVER demoed to IN. Can you show me some proof of IN having seen anymore then a powerpoint preso on this?

    in reply to: Military Aviation News from around the world – V #2425625
    Rimmer
    Participant

    I dont see US offering F-35 anytime in the near future…

    in reply to: Serbian Air Force has started lookig in to new fighters #2425664
    Rimmer
    Participant

    How is 30y old Chinese copy, of 50y old Russian design, with 20y old radar, and firing 32y old AIM 9L … a “quantum” leap over current MiG29 (few as they are) and MiG21 Bis ??? JF17 would hardly be a “quantum leap” over those, let alone AC it replaces.

    Not quite, but not far from the truth. However F7s would hardly help that situation. Like i have said, if they wanted to go down that path why not upgrade existing MiG21s to Bison??? Get proper BVR capability. Because they are not interested in spending money on obsolite design. Rather stick with what you have until you can procure something worthwile. .

    Also,since when is the AIM-9M 30 years old? What books have you been reading?

    Read above.

    Neither do I… ever. MiG29/35 on the other hand makes perfect sense. Heck we even have facilities to conduct complete overhaul and maitenece in Serbia.

    You also seem to not reading what ive said. Gripen would be perfect for us.. but the problem is US content and weapons… so why would you suggest 30y old AIM9L which made by which country???? :rolleyes:

    Only reasonable thing to do with all versions of MiG21/F7s at this point in time, is scrap metal. Cheap models like JF17,LCA, T50 (FA50) with much better preformance and equipment levels nulify only reason that justified those aircraft being kept in existance …. which is cost.

    If you look at Romanian Lancer example you will see that a MIG-21 airframe with amodern radar (which Grifo certianly is) and AIM-9M is a potent combo for basic interception duties.

    I wont reply to the cheap snipe at JF-17, its not part f this thread,and shows some ignorance.

    As mentioned, such a capability would be better then 30 year old MIG-21s and MIG29s. In fact, we dont even know if the current Serb AF would be capable of availability let alone upgrades….

    You are right, in an ideal world you should wait for Gripen, but it seems you dont have the time or money. I also doubt you have the trained manpoer to operate such adavnced aircraft without a long period of training Serb pilots and engineers.

    in reply to: Serbian Air Force has started lookig in to new fighters #2425737
    Rimmer
    Participant

    I hope they end up in Bosnia or Albania… anything being “replaced” by JF17 can be safely assumed to be old, obsolite and useless. Since JF17 is rated at 15-20 Million, and can be equiped with Israely,Russian,Chinese or Western radar avionics might as well go for that.. taking mig21 derivetives even for free would be terrible idea.

    We could probably equip j22s with AAMs and have good enough AC for “policing”. I think SrAF is looking for maintaining culture and capability of modern AF, at limited budget… which is why getting limited number of modern units if better way to go, than getting a lot of old and obsolite. 40-50 mig 21 derivatives will cost you over 10 years more than 12 Mig 29/35s yet provide nowhere near same cabability.. even if we were to get them for free.

    Maintanence , upgrades, training 40-50 crews and service personel… all costing fortune, yet offering 0 capability.

    Might as well get 40-50 spitfires and use that… would make the Arifroce one hell of a tourist attraction.

    Funny how you talk down unducting such planes. Yet anyoen can see 40-50 Grifo equipped and AIM-9L F-7PGs would be a quntam leap in capability in forSerb AF. Right now anyone could fly over Serbia almost unchallanged. If you do wish Bosnia or Kosovo took these planes, that would gives thme a much better equppied air force, and I dont see Serbian pilots in Rafales or Typhoons anytime soon….

Viewing 15 posts - 196 through 210 (of 542 total)