dark light

Andy in Beds

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 15 posts - 2,776 through 2,790 (of 3,233 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: Favourite videos/dvds #1382207
    Andy in Beds
    Participant

    SFF
    The RNHF Sea Fury film is available on DVD. I got from their stall at Legends this year.
    And yes it is brilliant!!

    in reply to: What if #1383498
    Andy in Beds
    Participant

    Japanese expansion towards the Dutch East Indies and the oil reserves there were always going to bring America into the war.
    The Philippines which were an American colony and the Cavite naval base were always going to be a thorn in the side of the Japanese.
    They therefore had to eliminate the Philippines as a threat and to attack there meant that the powerful Pacific fleet would move in to support the Asiatic fleet and therefore the Pacific fleet needed to be eliminated too–all at the same time.
    A very ambitious plan indeed.

    However you box it up though, the Japanese were going to lose. It might not have been 1945 or 46 or 47 but they would have eventually lost.
    Even if the line of furthest advance had been San Diego they would have still lost. They just were not powerful enough to beat the USA outright.
    The lesson here is ‘before you start a war, make sure you’ve got what you need to finish it.’ I think Yamamoto knew this all along. He promissed he could play hell in the Pacific for a year but couldn’t promise anything after that.
    Cheers
    Andy

    in reply to: What if #1383663
    Andy in Beds
    Participant

    What if America had lost the war 😮 think harder :rolleyes: Anna 😀

    Mark 9
    what are you driving at here???

    in reply to: What if #1383832
    Andy in Beds
    Participant

    Even if the very worst thing that could have gone wrong at Midway had happened and that would have been the loss of the three Yorktown Class Carriers, USS Yorktown, Enterprise and Hornet it wouldn’t have meant final victory for the Japanese. Yes, it would have been a setback for the Americans–a very big setback but still only that. They still had USS Saratoga, USS Wasp and at a push the smaller USS Ranger. The first of the much bigger Essex class carriers were well on the way to completion and the conversion of the CVL Independence class from cruiser hulls were also underway. The number of escort carriers building were also enormous.

    The real battle in many respects that decided the Pacific war was the long drawn out battle of Guadalcanal.
    Here carriers weren’t so important as land based aircraft were the real force to be reckoned with on both sides. The attrition that both sides suffered here over six months in cruisers, destroyers and battleships was very great. Thing was again the Americans were always replacing losses with new ships and better ships–The Japanese just couldn’t build at that speed or incorporate new technology (like gun laying radar) into their designs. So once the pre-war excellently trained Imperial Japanese Navy crews were lost there were no replacements in ships or quality men.

    Thing is from the moment that the first shot was fired at Pearl Harbour the Japanese had really lost. It just took thousands and thousands of lives before they were convinced.
    What a waste!!

    in reply to: Crazymainer US Navy Quiz #8 #1384061
    Andy in Beds
    Participant

    Consolidated PB2Y-5R Coronado.
    Design but not build by Consolidated not a 5R

    -3R?
    I think the RAF received the -3R version.

    One of the 218 PB2Y’s built at Consolidated’s plant at San Diego Ca.
    The plant is not in San Diego how many of this version were build

    NAF at Philadelphia??

    The UK link is that 10 of these aircraft were supplied under Lend-Lease and used by the RAF as transports.
    Yes on the RAF

    As far as CM’s family goes I haven’t a clue but suspect an older Rohr might have had some connection.

    Oh so close but how

    Your dad flew them–I know he was a Naval Officer. 🙂 😉 😉 🙂

    Any one??

    in reply to: Crazymainer US Navy Quiz #8 #1384178
    Andy in Beds
    Participant

    Try this….

    Right
    it’s Saturday night , there’s nothing on the tele and for once we’re staying in. So, I reckon it’s a Consolidated PB2Y-5R Coronado.
    One of the 218 PB2Y’s built at Consolidated’s plant at San Diego Ca.
    The UK link is that 10 of these aircraft were supplied under Lend-Lease and used by the RAF as transports.
    As far as CM’s family goes I haven’t a clue but suspect an older Rohr might have had some connection.
    Any good??
    Andy.

    in reply to: What if #1384202
    Andy in Beds
    Participant

    I agree with The Colonel

    The war in the Pacific was like most other wars a war of attrition.
    Once the US ship building and aircraft industries got into top gear the Japanese were always going to lose.
    You’ve only got to look at how quick the Yanks were turning out destroyers (for instance) even by the end of 1942 to see the inevitable end of events.

    Mark 9, I’m curious to know why you’re after this information???? 😀 😀 😉 😀

    in reply to: 26th October 2004: Bournemouth University #1384233
    Andy in Beds
    Participant

    Enough nubile totty and the eyes don’t see so far!

    Melv
    it was probably the thought of nubile totty that ruined your eyes in the first place 😀 😀 😉 😀

    in reply to: 26th October 2004: Bournemouth University #1385598
    Andy in Beds
    Participant

    Bravo Andy – you obviously have inside knowledge.
    Now can anyone, other than Andy, translate Andy’s comments into something more useful which give people the desire to get down there, heckle and report back on the forum?

    Actually Janie
    I saw it on the RAeS website while I was in the States. Steve Patterson was trying to weedle his way into the RAeS at the time–of course they won’t have him, being an American (even Charles Lindberg was rejected) and he didn’t go to Cambridge–well he did but only to go shopping there.

    But seriously Melvyn Hiscock is this year doing The RAeS memorial lecture on the above date at the above venue.
    Melv, what’s the subject?
    Cheers
    Andy

    in reply to: 26th October 2004: Bournemouth University #1385737
    Andy in Beds
    Participant

    A challenge!
    Who can tell me what not-to-be-missed aviation-related event is happening at Bournemouth University on Thursday 28th October.

    Janie
    is it a memorial lecture on ‘How I Spent Four Years in a Hampshire Cowshed’
    or ‘Rearwin Restoration Made Easy’

    by that famous 47 year old Guitar playing Basingrad resident?
    His name escapes at present–Melvis Hancock I think it is. 😀 😀
    Cheers
    Andy

    in reply to: Hot news on WIX #1385933
    Andy in Beds
    Participant

    Will it be at Legends? 😀

    You’re at it again!!! 😀 😀 😉 😉 😀
    As I said on an earlier thread about the Corsair.
    This has been a very good year for the completion of restorations.
    Looking forward to seeing this one.
    Cheers
    Andy

    in reply to: Vintage Fighters FG-1D BuNo 67070 flies! #1386155
    Andy in Beds
    Participant

    This year has cetainly seen some very nice aircraft make first flights after long restorations. This is another.
    Long may it continue.
    Cheers
    Andy

    in reply to: Escape March 1945 #1387385
    Andy in Beds
    Participant

    What squadron was your father with when this happened?

    in reply to: A real Easy Quiz #1387571
    Andy in Beds
    Participant

    Chuck Yeager broke the sound barrier in 1947 in the Bell X-1–an aircraft copied from a British design (Miles M-52) which was cancelled by the very silly British Government (Ho-Hum)
    Cheers
    Andy

    in reply to: Midland Airshow Pics #1388819
    Andy in Beds
    Participant

    Is that Jump Seat or Jump Suit? Its important that we know 😀

    Oh, how we’ve missed your lightning wit Nick.

    Good holiday??
    Any pictures of the Arizona?
    Give me a ring.
    Cheers
    Andy

Viewing 15 posts - 2,776 through 2,790 (of 3,233 total)