Quote:
Originally Posted by Wanderlei
hmm, you sound too confident on all matters. How do you know their only means of communication?
-Defected North Korean officers and soldiers said so. There are hundreds of former North Korean officers who have defected.
Quote:Wanderlei
What makes you, or anyone be sure that China’s radar, and satellite surveillance is not being fed to NK military constantly, or per need.
-Defected North Korean officers said so.
Quote:Wanderlei
This is hard to prove, and blame China for, while really easy to integrate in my opinion.
-China doesn’t trust North Korea.
China supplying weapons to North Korea is like the US supplying weapons to Taiwan; there is always the risk that North Korea would turn around and become US ally leading the China-containment effort, so supplying arms to North Korea is both politically risky and is against the UN arms embargo.
Quote:Wanderlei
Do you think China was not scanning for those B-52s and even B-2s ?
-Obviously the PLA is not telling if they picked up B-2 or not.
Quote Wanderlei:
I see no reason China and North Korea would not have similar setup.
– Because NK and China are not military allies, only political allies that could sour at any moment, such as Kim Jong Il’s secret 2009 offer to the US to become a US ally against China if the US signed a non-aggression treaty, normalized diplomatic relations, and lifted economic sanctions.
Quote:
Originally Posted by jbritchford
You also don’t seem to understand the structure of logical arguments – you don’t accept a proposition as true until it is disproved, it’s the other way around. You only accept a proposition once you have a good reason to.
Is there any evidence or motivation for China passing such information to NK?
Well, it’s obvious that Wanderlei is a Chinese poster and his view represents the typical Chinese views, which is obviously very different from everybody else’s. Chinese actually believe they are a significant factor in the current situation, when China is being ignored by both North and South Korea in this context, and the only thing China can bring onto the table is a possible military intervention in the event of the ROK invasion of North Korea as per the previously described automatic triggers.
@ SlowMan and jbritchford
Everything is so OBVIOUS to you.
Its pretty obvious to me that it is the other way around! Both of you guys are fixed only you being right, and all your info paints the only true picture of situation. Thats called preaching. Preachers don’y learn much.
“defected officers said” when? This year?, last year, any links? Not that I don’t trust you that they said so. I don’t trust that its that way just because they say so.
If you go back to where i first posted about Chinas radars assisting NK’s air defenses, I was asking for opinions, and looking for information. Definitely not trying to preach to anyone. I don’t trust anyone, so I question your statement specially because you answered very short without any explanation.
Also, am not Chinese poster, as it was so OBVIOUS to you. I am Serbian, and am looking to learn more about military strategic cooperation and relationships in asia. Specially about less obvious things. Your responses were short and direct about things that cannot be confirmed. Such as how much China would communicate with NK during all out war.
enjoy your wisdom.
Sign In
