dark light

TomcatViP

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 15 posts - 4,126 through 4,140 (of 5,621 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: How would you re-build the Argentinian military aviation? #2235195
    TomcatViP
    Participant

    Possible, yes, but the cost would be prohibitive. The cost of R&D for the changes would have to be borne by Argentina, & it would make Gripen very expensive.

    Saab is working on the T-X with Boeing. Even if Boeing has denied that there is a commonality in platforms, could it be that somewhat, something, will come out of that for the Argentinians ?

    But anyhow, IMOHO it would be a really bad move from BAE to not take that opportunity to step back in Sth America. I mean, how can you see the UK industry succeding there while the UK is still applying an out of age embargo alone to a country that dreams only of gaining some points of the international market with its relatively cheap educated labor? The good old day of Chegevara are gone. Such are the Juntas. Why will then anyone in the UK endorse the old fashioned duffle coat of the Iron Lady ?

    Think about that, the retaliation of tomorrows are a mix of economic sanctions and flexed military muscles…

    in reply to: AirAsia Airbus A320 gone missing #486323
    TomcatViP
    Participant

    First BlackBox recovered

    At 7:11, we succeeded in lifting the part of the black box known as the flight data recorder,” Fransiskus Bambang Soelistyo, head of the National Search and Rescue Agency, told reporters at a news conference.

    The second so-called black box, containing the cockpit voice recorder, is located about 20 meters away from where the flight data recorder was found, but divers have not yet been able to get to it.

    “(The cockpit voice recorder) seems to be under a wing, which is quite heavy,” said Supriyadi, operations coordinator for the search and rescue agency. “So we will use air bags to lift it. This will be done tomorrow.”

    Some suspect an in flight dislocation of the fuselage (Official source said an explosion but the way part’s edges are cut on the rare picture I have seen doesn’t seems to concur to that – I mean we would have expected dented sections with sharp edges in that case)

    Given the reported position of the 2nd recorder, a high energy impact with the water seems more plausible and will explain why such a tiny portion of the aft fuselage was found still attached with the tail (structure collapse like a car in frontal crash as opposed to a fuselage sectioning)

    Source:
    http://www.reuters.com

    in reply to: Good results -again- for Boeing ; #486327
    TomcatViP
    Participant

    114 787 delivered. That’s roughly 10 per months !

    in reply to: Indian Air Force Thread 20 #2235205
    TomcatViP
    Participant

    I understand Hallow. i understand.

    What I am saying is that perhaps some polite Indians are humbly showing a way out for Dassault that they don’t have to fall down the stairs…

    My own 2 cents obiously

    in reply to: Indian Air Force Thread 20 #2235234
    TomcatViP
    Participant

    Isn’t that price hike a peace with honor policy ? I mean a convenient way to cancel the deal for both parties ? The article even suggest that some compensation could be claimed for the apparent violation of the process and the loss of time. Would be interesting to follow.

    in reply to: Low Level…… #2235236
    TomcatViP
    Participant

    I am not sure that kind of FOD was ever envisioned by even the wisdom of a Kelly.

    To say the least… if that picture is real (the one with the 104 over the crowd)… It’s pretty stupid

    in reply to: Military Aviation News-2015 #2235388
    TomcatViP
    Participant

    Turkey Insists on Indigenous Fighter Jet

    “The decision on the program means that we will be switching from the feasibility phase to pre-design phase. In other words, this is an official mark that says the program has been found technically and financially feasible.”

    […]
    Turkey clearly wants to make a 100 percent local aircraft. This rules out any deal with a foreign manufacturer based on a foreign model. In other words, ‘Turkifying’ a foreign aircraft is no longer an option.

    Impressive. Meanwhile, we have to concede that somewhere in Eu it’s more like this:

    “Spieglein, Spieglein, an der Wand,
    Wer ist die Schönste im ganzen Land?”

    I wonder if someone at Mbb, somewhere deep into the blackforest, ever heard such tale… 😉

    Souce:
    http://www.defensenews.com/ (as quoted above)
    GrimmBrothers

    in reply to: RuAF News and development Thread part 14 #2236106
    TomcatViP
    Participant

    http://vimeo.com/115423809

    Cool Su-30SM video.

    Very nice vid indeed. Thx for sharing.

    in reply to: "in hindsight, they should've bought this instead" thread #2237748
    TomcatViP
    Participant

    Humble apologies… But they might need you back more than you believe 😉

    in reply to: AirAsia Airbus A320 gone missing #486556
    TomcatViP
    Participant

    No. It’s time for real-time tracking of Airline behavior via a direct access to plane’s data by a central organisation empowered to act directly and on time. I would even suggest a direct transfer of suspect variable to Interpol (cargo, respected delay at airport, parts ordered, equipage modification etc…).

    Just like in other industry, Self regulation by airlines doesn’t work every time, everywhere and in every situation. As we are now all “Citizen of the airways”, it’s time we bring what works down here up-there, no ?

    in reply to: Stealth AAM, why not? #2237916
    TomcatViP
    Participant

    Heaven forbid someone contribute to a thread with new info rather than just hurling insults.

    Why don’t you lay out for us what you think you know about this missile’s RCS? With a turbojet engine and a passive seeker there is no obvious reason this missile couldn’t be quite stealthy.

    Even if it isn’t particularly stealthy the fact that such a proposal has been advanced and funded for development speaks to some of the concerns posters in this thread have articulated about the potential utility of a relatively slow and/or loitering missile. (At least in theory a turbojet or low-bypass turbofan powered missile could be supersonic.)

    You know, if it has time (long range subsonic), instead of accelerating at Supersonic speed, it could simply fully deploy a wing set and climb very high. That kind of Missile can have a high aspect ratio wing more easily than a jet. Think about that. Remind that U2 climb ? The same here. Climb as high as possible given the launch condition (you don’t want to accelerate) then adopt a cruise/climb.

    Just when it has reached and detects the engagement conditions, wing fold like a VG plane and the missile accelerates in a dive. Then at close range M2+ (?), the booster is lighted and there you go: separation of the wing/body+Tank and you have a very long range missile able to loiter with a terminal kinetic hit.

    In fact, when you think about it, your idea is not that stupid.

    Imagine an Anti-Awac mission. The long range guidance is via passive Signal detection and datalink, then it switch in AARM mode and then H2K. Somewhat more expensive than a Sidewinder but it who knows ?

    TomcatViP
    Participant

    The relatively outdated Mirage 2000C didn’t make the cut against the latest F-16/F-18. The French offered the then new but not yet flying Mirage 2000-5 later in the competition, but were rejected.
    My opinion: the F-18C had the better radar (APG-73 vs RDI) and better missiles (AIM-120 vs Super 530). Better STOL performance is a bonus. The Hornet may not have the edge up high and fast, but the Swiss model with -402 engines and low drag pylons climbs way better than older Hornets. […]

    Don’t forget the superior high Alpha handling that might have played a lot in the way Swiss intended flying their planes. Also, prior to the MLU on the 16, the 18 had the best available avionics in the west.

    On that subject, Swiss AF really should have gone for the A-7G in 1972. The Corsair crushed the competition, but due to mentioned pressure from France trying to sell the inferior Milan, the gov. decided instead to buy neither and opted for 30 used Hunters instead. That effectively was the end for serious air to ground business in Switzerland. The Hunters were kept in the A-G role until 1994 but that was hardly state of the art…

    Well, can we say that with proper hindsight, and given the Switzerland debacle, Fr would have dealt better with India [/CristalballMode=OFF] ?

    The F-4F wasn’t a bad choice. Thanks to reduced weight and maneuvering slats, it was a good performer. With 2 sets of eyes and 4 Sidewinders plus gun certainly better than the F-104. The F-4 also was an excellent (interim) conventional fighter bomber, unlike the Starfighter. What else would have been available in the early 70s? The F-15 a few years later maybe. Tornado ADV wasn’t really ready until the Cold War was more or less over.

    Let’s put things in contest. In the early 70’s, after Vietnam and the Yom Kippur war, choosing the F4 was a no-brainer (load, tech, speed, true multi-mission, sexiness…)

    Last but not least, given the popularity of that thread, should we grants its author a prize for being already the Best in 2015 or is that a lack of proper hindsight?

    TomcatViP
    Participant

    Why should subsidizing of uncompetitive companies be of any concern to me ? I’m interested in affordable eqipment for our armed forces. Now we have those overly expansive crap equipment sitting on the tarmac, and no money left for continous upgrades and pilot training. German bureaucracy and EADS have proven over and over again they can’t handle project management. Oh, and I forgot the A400M. A mix of C17’s, C-27’s and MRTT’s would have been cheaper and delivered on schedule.

    The recent EC 645 procurement is an example of how it can work, existing design with some minor modifications, one year between contract signature and first flight.

    Besides, arms deals always include offsets. This would benefit competive industries instead of the failure that is EADS/Cassidian/Airbus military.

    +1

    But the C27 is very small if you want to Hub&Spoke

    And the EC645/Bk117 is still for me an old Bo105 revamped

    TomcatViP
    Participant

    Tiger was designed as a (sophisticated) tank hunter, and has since looked for a reason to exist (apart from straffing lost talibans).

    Strange… I had in mind that the Apache was successful…

    NH90 suffered from program delays and quality issues that pissed off impatient customers who expected perfection (think F-35).

    LoL. Thanks for the humor… Oh… You intend to be serious ?

    Eurocopter is no more, being renamed Airbus Helicopters, but was hailed as one of the most successful helo companies. Let’s see if Airbus can walk in those shoes.

    Do you mean Aerospatiale ?

    May I remind you that yesterday Eurocopter and today AirbusM most successful products are still the one derived from old Aerospatiale and MBB?

    in reply to: AirAsia Airbus A320 gone missing #486562
    TomcatViP
    Participant

    Another AIRASIA A320 engine fails just prior takeoff in Surabaya

    Flight QZ7633 (registration PK-AZC), bound for Bandung, departed Juanda International Airport and had taxied about 3m before the Airbus A320’s engine died. There was an explosion, which spooked the 120 passengers on board.

    A passenger, Yusuf Fitriadi, told Metro TV that a pilot told passengers waiting at the departure lounge the starter monitor had malfunctioned.

    “The plane was ready and had moved when we suddenly heard a bang. The engine died and the plane moved backwards. We started panicking,” Yusuf told the TV station.

    The flight departed about two hours later, although a number of passengers reportedly refused to board the flight.

    I wonder if such incident can’t be related to the battery with a surge in the electrical system .We have discussed something similar early in the MH370 thread.

    Source:

    http://malaysianews.info/airasia-a320-engine-fails-a-few-minutes-before-takeoff-in-surabaya/

Viewing 15 posts - 4,126 through 4,140 (of 5,621 total)