dark light

Stirling

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 50 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: Condition of aircraft #747829
    Stirling
    Participant

    I strongly suspect this is the Cosford Catalina castoff

    in reply to: Stirling Project Update #750233
    Stirling
    Participant

    Great progress, I wasn’t aware there is a museum at RAF Downham Market , could you provide further details is it open or a proposed one? the only thing I can find online is a proposed memorial? 

    Stirling
    Participant

    A good bartering point to knock the price down is the fact that it has the metal wings rather than the correct wood wings that have a visually obvious wider chord to the wing tips. Don’t think anson mk1s ever had metal wings fitted during ww2? I wonder whether Canada has any wood wing drawings, I understand Avro lost the original drawings in the chadderton fire in around 1960.

    Stirling
    Participant

    I too made a week of it starting with my first time at the Cosby show on Saturday and i was, like others i overheard amazed at the contrast of the  B17 display away from Dux; it was banked over at approx 350ft all way down showline which was L shaped so it also felt like it was circling you , it wasn’t just 3 flat flybys and land like at Dux. The Catalina was there and what a STOL aircraft it is when light, the £5 to go on board was a bargain. Mind you the Catalina show landing was a bit sporty curved approach right down to hard on main wheel which threw it  hard onto noseleg before the other main – for a split second it was pointing straight for crowd  – if it had ploughed in and slewed.. good job ground was rock hard and I overheard one of the crew discussing landing after. After the B17 it was the P51 Contrary Mary and what suprising letdown act as no aeros IIRC and dull natural metal just didn’t work against the sky compared to the olive drab of the B17.

    Duxford I did Friday as these days  no smart phone means no tickets can be bought, still i wasn’t moaning as the cost saving meant I could spend more on books – I noted there were fewer book stalls than the previous year infact maybe only one The Aviation Bookshop but they had some superb multibuy bargains. Speaking to the campsite warden they normally get alot of Duxford visitors but they  were noticeably quieter than normal and hardly any overseas visitors..  I was intrigued that the TFC Fiat CR42 has now been disassembled compared to last year when it was visually complete and engine inhibited, Choosing my words carefully; apparently the contracted out work has not been to desired standard and so requires some remedial work , I suspect  therefore it may well need some fabric recovering as well.

     

    in reply to: Aircraft Fragment from Northumberland ID – Junkers? #759595
    Stirling
    Participant

    I would be looking to see what size spanner the brass bolt head corresponds to exactly BA or metric , american etc to give clue of country of origin, it may even unscrew and u could check thread with gauge, it looks to be quite small in size. The bolt head may also have mark on it that could identify its type/origin but it looks to just have a circular depression although that may well signify something. 

    It does look fairly modern

    in reply to: Arco Duxford advertising for piston engineers #760751
    Stirling
    Participant

    So reading into this  is the emphasis increasingly going forward more on volume  GA vintage  (eg. cubs , moths and chippies) rather than big piston warbird resto, This would seem to chime with a the vibe that the UK warbird scene appears  somewhat deflated compared to recent decades and big ticket projects seem to be glacial in progress.

    in reply to: Stirling Project Update #761002
    Stirling
    Participant

    Interesting times and good luck with the move . Regarding BK716  was there any evidence of the wing as it looks like fuselage and engine nacelle related items only in the photos ,  I recall  hypothesising in the past that there may have been a partial clearup wartime as the video of the recovery similarly showed no evidence of wing primary structure IIRC?

    in reply to: Large chunk of airframe -Ebay France #761274
    Stirling
    Participant

    Not seen this style on a Ju88, there is an unfamiliar vibe about the style of construction such that I get a vibe it could be French airframe, on account of the construction being somewhat eccentric with some very fine rivet pitches and then pitch changes significantly along stringers also several unnecessarily different profile stringers and the lightening holes smack of final desperation to keep airframe weight down. It’s like this area of airframe has had various manf mods to make it stiffer and/or the design is not one of efficient rationalized mass production its complex for no good design reason in my eyes.  There are traces of light blue like Germans and French used. 

    Also that piston is i think too small for aero engine.

    in reply to: New -build JU-52 project unveiled #761439
    Stirling
    Participant

    Well given enough time and money anything is possible, but there may still be few customers. Being older in concept the ju52 is a less aerodynamically efficient airframe than the dc3 so unless they want to ditch many of the fundamental features that make it characteristically a ju52, except maybe the tri motor layout, then your potential customer has to be happier buying something that has inferior performance to a DC3. 

    As for the new unproven engines: all that needs to be said is contained in AVwebs Paul Bertorellis excellent presentation on why new aircraft engine ideas rarely succeed:

    https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=_k1TQGK3mZI

    in reply to: Stick identity sought #761549
    Stirling
    Participant

    As mentioned earlier very similar to Harvard  – hows about T 28 trojan? – which would explain the paint colour which has a modern look to it.

    in reply to: What ever happened to…..Ken Ward's collection? #762040
    Stirling
    Participant

    I have heard that some items have found their way to ebay in more recent times. I seem to get some conflicting info though as to where the collection ended up I  was told RAF Leeming more recently but I’m not sure of this. What I don’t understand is why the MoD didn’t just claim it as all their property and confiscate immediately ? Maybe they could not prove he hadn’t bought it all legitimately? Either way the whole sorry saga sounds like an utter mess with no winner the result that possibly the best highground relic collection in UK may just end up split amongst private collections forever never to see the light of day. At least he was amenable to visitors to the collection and to my eternal regret I never took the offer up.

    Off the back of all this legitimate legal recoveries are all but dead and no doubt illegal ones  carry on as normal, and so the source of wreckage is constrained a little driving prices higher, great if you are a dealer.

    Perhaps a perfect example of how regulation solves nothing. There again it looks like the regulation is largely toothless, so go ahead anyway!

     

     

     

     

    in reply to: Dornier 217 Relic help to Identify. #762268
    Stirling
    Participant

    Looks to have a steel bar balance weight in the small radius leading edge which also appears to be flat bottomed  so suggestive of a frise type control surface normally used on ailerons. They used several visually different styles of control surface balance weights on the Dornier and other German aircraft which should help to narrow it down. if it’s 217 I think likely  outer most part of aileron as other control surfaces appear to be balanced externally.  Bill Gunstons aircraft cutaway book will help but captions cannot be always trusted to be correct.

    in reply to: Peak year for UK classic airshows was? #762834
    Stirling
    Participant

    I very much concur and had no idea a Varsity was on the circuit at one stage. The jet issue is almost inevitable, in fact for me it’s the lack of multis that is the great shame at the moment, it is also suprising that there are no UK DC3 operator doing pleasure flights as dakotanorway.no have been successfully working around the escape slide issue for a decade… i sense a lack of enthusiasm. Within the next half decade IMO the only big ticket rare UK projects vintage piston projects I know of that may get airborne is the CR42 and just maybe a Mossie. The Dutch based Fokker XXI is also a hugely significant project IMO and and a likely visitor.

    in reply to: Peak year for UK classic airshows was? #762931
    Stirling
    Participant

    Whilst somewhat subjective it was more around the historic aircraft rather than those then in service at the time of the show and more wrt the sheer volume of different types,.whilst 1980/90s was no doubt buzzing with famous ww2 pilots on ground  and derring-do do display’s, I wonder if the peak in terms of variety, display quality and volume was later and post 2000 when a lot of rare projects appear and the sheer number of  by then restored aircraft and maybe a more established international movement of warbirds , plus German based aircraft were entering the mix as well.

    in reply to: 5CX/5364 #762944
    Stirling
    Participant

    Induction heaters – no idea of prices I just borrowed one.

Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 50 total)