dark light

BSG-75

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 15 posts - 2,956 through 2,970 (of 3,576 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: Israel and French F-84s #1173254
    BSG-75
    Participant

    Whether they were borrowed, or just French aircraft operating ‘covertly’ from Israel is one of those questions….

    There are a couple of books that cover Suez operations and cover this IIRC

    I’m reading “Suez 1956 – the story of the first oil war” now – not got as far as the attack yet, but I recall even at “O” level history being taught that the French AF used Israel bases for the F-84’s while the Uk used RN aircraft and Cyprus (off thread…. a long way, but Hunters would have the range?) & Malta for Canberra’s etc.

    Good book BTW – very readable like Anthony Beevor etc.

    in reply to: Mk II Westland Whirlwind ‘What if’ #1173898
    BSG-75
    Participant

    Hi

    Therefore in answer to all the long standing internet debates, Westlands in 1941, put in writing that the whirlwind airframe could handle merlin engines..

    Cheers
    Jerry

    Nice one – thank you – my own resource is somewhat limited in comparison, I was looking at “interceptor” by James Goulding which quotes pretty much what I said as does Tony Buttler, but I’m guessing that has all been discussed a million times already !

    What if indeed……….. thanks for the info.

    in reply to: General Discussion #297479
    BSG-75
    Participant

    I’ve always regarded Ledger as a B grade actor and bad one at that..i think it’s all a sympathy vote

    There will always be an element of that I agree – it gets all American and OTT, Oscars are a sham anyway IMHO (Shawshank Redemption anybody?) and best actor for a comic strip role is not my idea of what it should be – that said, if you can enjoy a Batman film, I would say that as above, this guy just steals it and looks utterly, totally barking mad.

    in reply to: The Last Film You Saw….. 3D!!!! #1887019
    BSG-75
    Participant

    I’ve always regarded Ledger as a B grade actor and bad one at that..i think it’s all a sympathy vote

    There will always be an element of that I agree – it gets all American and OTT, Oscars are a sham anyway IMHO (Shawshank Redemption anybody?) and best actor for a comic strip role is not my idea of what it should be – that said, if you can enjoy a Batman film, I would say that as above, this guy just steals it and looks utterly, totally barking mad.

    BSG-75
    Participant

    I’ve a lot of time for Harris, think he was badly treated by the powers that be then, and historians since, but he did seem to have a blind spot when it came to supporting the UK lifelines.

    Moggy

    I agree – there was a marvelous passage in “Nemesis” by Max Hastings about Harris and other leaders who have been judged in such a way (Curtis Le May as well) – lent the book out now so don’t have it to hand, its a good read BTW, went along the lines of Churchill especially, and Roosevelt both sacked military leaders on a regular basis and if there was any hint of unhappiness from the leaders on the bombing policy, then they would have been replaced at a whim.

    As for the “20 times the damage” theory – it doesn’t hold out in such black and white terms, interesting point but the argument would be stronger with some maths.

    BSG-75
    Participant

    Interesting thread (as always) on the forum – interesting to see the Halifax “excluded” from the get go – as for the initial question, I read some interesting comments somewhere by Jon Lake about the contribution of the B-24. IIRC – the RAF used something like 3 or maybe 4 times as many B-24’s as Sunderlands and he stated – with no great confirmation of the maths – that each B-24 in RAF Coastal Command did “20 times more damage” to the German war effort than a Bomber Command 4 engined heavy.

    Not saying this is correct in anyway – but worth a thought ?

    I think it was in International Air Power Review – need to go dig them out.

    in reply to: What, when, where? #1176107
    BSG-75
    Participant

    very interesting

    A Lancaster (maybe Manchester?) fusalage, the engines look more Lincoln style in installation, even taking into account the shrouding etc for the tests.

    in reply to: Canadian Museum's Hampden Damaged by Snow Fall #1176261
    BSG-75
    Participant

    when all else fails….

    No, it says that the guy who carried out the work logged a flight in it during the war following repairs, although it isnt phrased very well.

    Bruce

    used to have a science teacher at school, in every test he would write “when all else fails, read the question” on the board – now I read it, you are quite right ! – (I do still have a slight Rioja head from last night though……)

    and from the picture, you can clearly see its not a complete airframe.

    in reply to: Canadian Museum's Hampden Damaged by Snow Fall #1176303
    BSG-75
    Participant

    check the museum WWW site

    I think from this you can deduce two things.

    1) It was not restored/replicated/re-engineered/re-created etc to original works specification.

    2) In consequence it will be relatively easy to repair.

    Mark

    http://www.canadianflight.org/content/handley-page-hampden

    In my total ignorance, I never even knew there was a Hampden intact, it says here that it made a flight post restoration ? Read down to the end, if this is the case the rebuild must have been substantial? :confused:

    in reply to: Mk II Westland Whirlwind ‘What if’ #1176319
    BSG-75
    Participant

    IIRC Merlins were too big and too heavy for the design, Petter designed the aircraft to be as small as possible – maybe an “upscale” would have worked but as discussed here on many threads by us Whirlwind lovers/what ifs etc, Westland were too small a company to do it, Spitfires etc were the order of the day – Whirlwinds & MB-5’s got lost along the way.

    in reply to: General Discussion #297759
    BSG-75
    Participant

    Lions For Lambs

    Thoughtful, maybe a little flawed in the timelines built into the script, but interesting commentary on George W’s wars and the way they are fought and reported.

    Well worth 85 mins of your time……

    in reply to: The Last Film You Saw….. 3D!!!! #1887252
    BSG-75
    Participant

    Lions For Lambs

    Thoughtful, maybe a little flawed in the timelines built into the script, but interesting commentary on George W’s wars and the way they are fought and reported.

    Well worth 85 mins of your time……

    in reply to: Mk II Westland Whirlwind ‘What if’ #1177144
    BSG-75
    Participant

    Middle East/Malta & long range fighter sweeps into Europe, maybe escort the Banff wing Mossies/Beaus as well?

    in reply to: Jerry Scutts #1177399
    BSG-75
    Participant

    Four actually (at least),

    Tim

    My apologies Tim – no deliberate intent to leave out any names etc at all on my part.

    in reply to: Jerry Scutts #1177409
    BSG-75
    Participant

    Thats three writers lost in 2008? Chaz Bowyer, Ray Sturtivant and now Jerry Scutts – I can see copies of work by all of them from where I sit – another sad loss.

Viewing 15 posts - 2,956 through 2,970 (of 3,576 total)