dark light

PLA-MKII

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 15 posts - 1,366 through 1,380 (of 1,462 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: Air War Over Iran – Possible Scenarios #2567651
    PLA-MKII
    Participant

    JDW report that iran is upgrading there F-14 and F-14 with russian radar system and engine,is there picture of it?

    I wish!!

    in reply to: Chinese exports, part III! #2567653
    PLA-MKII
    Participant

    I really like the K-8. While the L-15 design is great, its got two engines which could mean twice the maintenance. What I’d ideally want is a more powerful K-8 or a single engined L-15..

    in reply to: Air War Over Iran – Possible Scenarios #2567655
    PLA-MKII
    Participant

    Since we are playing a stretching game, So y not i stretch a little aswell. So i put this stretch in the mix.
    What if Stinger missiles from Pakistan find their way across the boarder to Iran. Considering its a hand held model so taking out these targets is almost impossible. What would the latest USAF A/C do against their own technology working against them.
    Comments guys?

    stingers are not that effective against the kind of campaign the US would be engaging. But S-300PMUs well those are a different ball game altogether and when coupled with layered SAM defenses and some form of air cover they are a challenge – a challenge that can be overcome but a challenge nevertheless..

    in reply to: Air War Over Iran – Possible Scenarios #2567673
    PLA-MKII
    Participant

    China’s Jh-7s wheren’t spotted till years after they became operational. You’re right about ACIG it does specialize but Tom Cooper’s reliability to me went down from the moment he started covering Pakistan – the garbage he churned out made me suspicious of how good he was at what he’s been doing with Iran. In any case a “secret” project or buy would remain just that – no loose lips and specially not old sources from the Shah’s airforce era.. and just for stretching it a bit 🙂 imagine a hidden airbase located under a mountain or something similar..

    in reply to: Air War Over Iran – Possible Scenarios #2567877
    PLA-MKII
    Participant

    an air war would be very interesting and in my opinion very unpredictable!nobody knows for sure how active the iranian air force is or what they could have ready for combat in a short period of time!how many fulcrums do they actually have?i think in AFM there was something about russia upgrading irans MiGs?i cant remember to what standard they said they are to be upgraded too?does anyone know what im talking about?

    Cheers! Iran follows a policy of secrecy similar to China’s unlike the US. It is hard to find out what kind of inventory they have. IMHO its not known how many MiGs where upgraded or if they where upgraded at all or what exactly is irans inventory. but here is globalsecurity’s list:

    http://www.globalsecurity.org/milit…e-equipment.htm

    in reply to: Air War Over Iran – Possible Scenarios #2568034
    PLA-MKII
    Participant

    nobody is saying that it will be an even fight. However, not all uneven fight ends 0-100. I’m simply considering all the possibilities and to me those claiming that ratio are living in a fantasy themselves.. the truth lies somewhere in between. Thats exactly what I am trying to get at. I NEVER claimed Iran does have MiG-31s.. all I’m saying is it is very probably they do have SOMETHING – could even be the J-8IIs with russian radars. But it easily could be the MiG-31s as well or even Su-27. I’m just accounting for the mystery plane factor with 15 MiG-31s and 15 F-22s on either side 🙂

    in reply to: Air War Over Iran – Possible Scenarios #2568549
    PLA-MKII
    Participant

    Next you’ll be dragging out the photoshops of Iranian Tu-22M3! Iran has absolutely no MiG-31s in their inventory. The same goes for any opertional S-300 system. None of those appear on any threat list for the region. There is a good reason for that as none of them exist in Iranian operational service.

    Stop living in a dream world! For the Iranians to operate such systems they have to train and operate them as part of their integrated defence system. And neither do they have operational MiG-25 courtesy of the Iraqis. Yet another rumour some individuals believe. It was exactly the same pre-Allied Force with fantasy claims of what the Serbs possessed.

    🙂 I am not claiming to be privy to any special knowledge but you seem to know exactly what the Iranian inventory has.. if you could list your sources it would be of great interest to all of us. As far as I know, the general prevalent view is that nobody knows exactly what the iranian capabilities are and how operational their AF is. I am not claiming the MiG-31 exists per se but merely that there is a very good PROBABILITY that there is a mystery plane that the iranians have..

    in reply to: Air War Over Iran – Possible Scenarios #2568619
    PLA-MKII
    Participant

    Had too much Flight Simulator and glued too many models I guess? But you obviously did not bother about modern air warfare.

    If a conflict starts (what I highly doubt), the US (or alliance) sets date, target and character of the campaign. The Iranians have no means of taking initiative. they have though a very good window seat and can watch first-hand how to do it right. Their air force is good for a two day interference, but after that they are either shot down, destroyed on the ground or so outnumbered, that only taking off becomes an act of bravery. An F-14 still gets most people excited, but an 1980s F-14A without Phoenix, proper AEW and in small numbers is less effective than an F-18E with one engine.

    Iran has no CCC to do any harm to US/alliance forces. If they are lucky they get at least some clue what is going on and try to improvise defence, maybe with the chance of a lucky shot. If they’re unlucky, they can only count the dead and call it a day.
    The US/alliance will take out AD first, concetrationg on well-known AEW-radars and SAM-sites, preferrably with cruise missiles. After that take out air fields and other CCC-targets. Some planes might get lost, but that is unlikely as US/alliance can concetrate their forces as they wish. They will always have local superiority and can reduce effectiveness of Iranian AD to a bare funny non-existant nothing.

    Losses:
    Iran: all that dare to interfere
    US/alliance: depends on their approach, if they take it slow and respect Iranian capabilities, the losses are zero due to enemy activity.

    That is not US-happy, MiG-bashing propaganda. That is just what will happen if the World’s best air force starts a conflict against the remainder of a 1980s air force.

    And please get serious and leave MiG-31 and S-300 out. Even if they have it, it won’t make a big difference.

    No worries mate but do realize that Iran isn’t Iraq and even one iraqi monkified MiG-25 was able to shoot down a hornet buzz another plane and ignore the F-15s chasing it.. Further, after seeing what US airpower did to Iraq, the Iranian pilots would fight to the end knowing what would happen if they didn’t.. nobody wants their country into a monkey house.

    in reply to: Air War Over Iran – Possible Scenarios #2568627
    PLA-MKII
    Participant

    A-2-S: I think cruise missiles will be used but will have limited impact on the air defense assets because of the lack of intelligence..

    On the MiG-31 Qtn here is a link:

    http://www.irandefence.net/showthread.php?t=645

    There have been sporadic reports about Mig31 presence over Iran. The most recent report which was provided by UAE Air Force officials told the story of one of their pilots who could spot a fast flying Iranian fighter close to the Abu Musa Island in the Persian Gulf. The UAE pilot could clearly see the Iranian fighter flying in parallel and after a short period turning deeply into the Iranian airspace. The pilot who was on a routine surveillance and photography mission could not take any pictures of the fighter but he was almost sure it was a Mig31 and not a F-14, Su27 or Mig 29 which normally appear in the Iranian sky.

    Israeli defense analysts have long tried to find out about the current capabilities of the Iranian Air Force and has therefore installed highly sensitive radars in the Iraqi Kurdistan close to Iran in order to better study the Iranian radar grids after the failed US unmanned flights into Iran which had the purpose to provoke the Iranians to turn on their radars in order for Americans to study the Iranian radar grids. However the Iranians never turned on their radars and in some rare cases they only turned on fixed radar batteries on a point wise fashion(one at a time) in order to just track the intruder’s path without giving any information about the networked air defense system.

    Once the presence of Israeli experts and equipments inside Iraqi Kurdistan was confirmed in September the Iranians continue to keep their ground radar systems off, but instead increased their aerial presence in order to ensure the enemy understands the Iranian air defense system is not purely relying on its ground network. The Iranian F-14s were flying 2-3 times the normal rate at high altitudes inside Iran close to the Western and South-Western border. This was combined by high level of activities of low flying Iranian F-4s and F-5s ensuring visual contact with any low flying object entering Iranian airspace. As the Israelis and Americans were collecting data on Iranian radar capabilities, during a night in October, they could, for up to 15 minutes, spot four high flying objects close to the Iranian Western border with their radars on. The surprising fact was that the airplanes were present at an even distance of 200 km from each other and covering an amazing area of 900 kilometers from Northwest to the Southwest border of Iran by hooking up their radars. The experts were shocked by this exercise which obviously and purposefully sent out a message to the other side ensuring the attackers understand the Iranian aerial radar capabilities could during a high-alert situation become active in minutes and cover a large area.

    Later on the experts were confused on how the Iranians could achieve such a degree of aerial radar capabilities as their current stock of fighters did not have any such capability. As they continued to look for an answer they could all agree on the fact that the non-confirmed Mig31 must be present in the Iranian Air Force’s inventory as that would be the only potential aircraft in Iran capable of hooking its radar and covering such a vast area.

    in reply to: China's News, Pics and Speculation Part 9 #2569167
    PLA-MKII
    Participant

    Don the PL-8C link doesn’t work

    in reply to: Air War Over Iran – Possible Scenarios #2569204
    PLA-MKII
    Participant

    My prediction 🙂
    First day: A sudden attack is intercepted by warry Iranian pilots, but the ensuing battle results in the loss of most of the Iranian aircraft in combat – 20 planes shot down including 5 tomcats, 4 MiG-29s and 2 MiG-31s. The airdefense system is half blown out as well but the Iranians manage to ward of the attack from the nuclear sites deeper in Iran. However, Bushehr lies in complete ruin and much of the infrastructure have at least limited damage.

    The US forces albeit partially successful, also suffer losses totalling 5 planes shot down – 3 of which are Super Hornets. Ironically, two of these were shot down by Iranian F-14As. The other two casualties are 1 each for the F-16 and F-15… more later

    in reply to: Air War Over Iran – Possible Scenarios #2569274
    PLA-MKII
    Participant

    LOL SOC I’m attempting to make it interesting that’s all. Take it as it is don’t complain :dev2:

    PhantomII I did include that read my post and the link I attached..

    Iranian F-14A I’m trying not to run away with my imagination 🙂

    A scenario like this is very likely in the near future and CMs are less likely to be effective given the heightened level of security within Iran.

    Also, MiG-31s.. rumors are rife that the iranians have a new “mystery” plane. Whether it is the MiG-31, F-8II, J-10, Su-27 or whatever it is there is a mystery plane (or so I believe). Thus I am assuming it to be the MiG-31 to account for the mystery plane… Mr. Berlusconi thinks otherwise but a new plane with new radar and BVR missiles as well as data linking would bring definitely have an impact for Iran..

    in reply to: conventional SUBMARINES vs ASW systems #2059964
    PLA-MKII
    Participant

    Sorry for going off topic but does anyone know the advantages / disadvantages of single hulled vs double hulled subs?

    PLA-MKII
    Participant

    The Kaveri will go online soon but whether it satisfies reqs is another question?

    “online” is the term to use I think 😉

    in reply to: India seals high-tech U.S. arms deal #2575042
    PLA-MKII
    Participant

    Truly a fine way to discuss global politics.. 😀 😀
    What animal would Iran be though?

Viewing 15 posts - 1,366 through 1,380 (of 1,462 total)